Why Dallas doesn't need a backup goalie change, and the numbers prove it

When the Dallas Stars signed Casey DeSmith last year to a quiet three-year deal, most fans didn't think much of it.

At the time, many wondered why the team was moving on from Scott Wedgewood, who posted similar numbers and had more history with the club.

But three months later, DeSmith wasn't just filling the role, he was thriving in it.

At one point in April, his .922 save percentage ranked second in the entire NHL behind only Connor Hellebuyck, beating out names like Andrei Vasilevskiy and Igor Shesterkin in fewer games played.

Casey DeSmith gives Dallas Stars playoff flexibility and long-term goalie insurance

In an article from D Magazine, David Castillo said it best:

"He's the best there is right now. Not only is that true of his observed save percentage, but also his save percentage when we account for the defense in front of both."

What makes DeSmith so valuable isn't just his numbers, but the timing.

With Jake Oettinger logging more minutes than almost any other NHL goalie since 2020, having a reliable backup means the Stars can finally consider load management to keep their starter fresh for the postseason.

Coach Pete DeBoer even trusted DeSmith to step in during a critical playoff game this spring, a rare move for a backup that signaled real confidence.

As D Magazine noted, DeSmith helped Dallas survive key injuries to Miro Heiskanen while the team was outshot badly during a critical stretch.

DeSmith's consistency helped stabilize the roster when the power play dipped and the defense sagged, and with him signed for two more years, the position seems locked in.

Even Dobber Hockey projected no changes in net for Dallas next year, with Remi Poirier remaining as the AHL option and no external moves expected.

Personally, I think keeping this tandem intact is one of Jim Nill's smartest decisions in recent years.