The transfer portal is a two-edged sword for former Alabama head coach and college football legend Nick Saban.
On the one hand, he believes that college football players having the freedom to get a change of scenery if they need it isn't a bad thing. That has always been the case, but it used to come with a loss of eligibility, and that made it hard for players who really needed greener grass to find a different home.
However, one of the reasons Saban and old-school coaches have grown irritated with the NIL and transfer portal era is that it has led to a free-for-all environment where players can get frustrated for literally any reason they want and leave their program. Sometimes it's not even about frustration, but rather, a competitive program is presenting them with a big-money NIL deal to try to lure them away.
In all, it has created an environment that will hurt the competitive spirit of college football, according to Saban. He said as much on "The Pat McAfee Show" on Thursday.
“Well I think it’s obviously good for the players if they can make that kind of money as college players, which was never allowed. We weren’t allowed to have anything prior to five years ago. But I do think, on the development side of it, it is not beneficial to players," Saban said (h/t On3's Andrew Graham). "I think when you have to go out and compete — and I don’t think you can be a good competitor, you mentioned it, if you can’t overcome adversity. That’s a part of being a good competitor. I don’t care what sport you're playing or when you’re playing, if it’s golf, if it’s tennis, if it’s soccer, I don’t care what it is: There’s going to be times when you have a bad play. There’s something that you have to overcome. And I think people learn to do that in the process of development and what they have to do to get better so they can compete.”
"I don't think you can be a great competitor if you can't overcome adversity..
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) December 19, 2024
I think people learn to do that in the process of development & all I ever promised a guy was an opportunity..
Guys bought into that because they wanted to develop value for their future" ~ Coach… https://t.co/ftPitMNQON pic.twitter.com/2aXg2WalSg
The college football recruiting and transfer portal environment has become all about promises, and sometimes false promises to players. There's more money, more playing time and less adversity on the other side of the street if you're willing to jump in the portal and make a move. To Saban's point, the system is now set up so that the first time a player has adversity, all he has to do is hit the transfer portal rather than sticking his head down and working through it.
Saban told McAfee that the only thing he ever promised his players was the opportunity to compete. He never promised anyone playing time or special treatment. In fact, the depth chart at Alabama was so stacked year after year that for many talented players, they were forced to wait their turn and learn and develop their skill.
It worked for Saban and the Tide, though, because he taught his players to look at the long term, which is something he believes is now being lost.
“That’s how you’re going to get better and guys bought into that because they were looking to the future. 'How can I develop value for my future?' Now guys are looking to ‘Where can I develop value right now? Today? What can I get today?’ So it’s less about playing and being a great player and more about ‘What can I get instantly?’ in terms of getting in the portal or going to another school," Saban explained. "Nobody talks about the college experience anymore. Nobody talks about graduation. All these things are probably important to the future."
These are all great points by Saban, but they're quickly becoming too old-school in today's environment. The damn has broken, and it's going to be hard to go back to the way things were. Not that it was all great back then, because it wasn't, but the shark may have been jumped a bit at this point.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!