Why the Blue Jays need to give up on Alek Manoah

There was a time when Alek Manoah appeared destined to be a top-of-the-rotation starter for the Toronto Blue Jays.

Manoah had an impressive 2022 season, posting a 2.24 ERA and a 0.992 WHiP over his 196.2 innings, striking out 180 batters with 51 walks. He was named to the All-Star Game and finished third in the American League Cy Young award vote. 

That season proved to be the high point of Manoah's career. He arrived at spring training in 2023 out of shape, setting off a firestorm when an MLB Network analyst said Manoah needed to spend more time in the gym. He struggled all season, posting a 5.87 ERA and a 1.740 WHiP over his 87.1 innings, striking out 79 batters but issuing 59 walks. Manoah spent a month in the Florida Complex League to work on mechanical issues and was later banished to Triple-A for the rest of the season.

Since then, Manoah has battled injuries and continued command issues, making just five appearances for the Blue Jays in 2024. His most recent rehab start following Tommy John surgery was a disaster as he allowed three runs on three hits and two walks while recording five outs. Manoah has posted an 11.57 ERA and a 2.714 WHiP over seven innings covering four starts, striking out six batters while issuing eight walks and hitting three batters. 

The Blue Jays have held out hope that Manoah could rediscover his 2022 form. However, each mediocre outing and injury puts that season further in the rearview mirror. Meanwhile, the Blue Jays are in the midst of a playoff push while eyeing the AL East title. They need players who can help down the stretch. Manoah has not displayed any signs that he can be part of the solution this year or in the future.

The Blue Jays continue to stand by Manoah in hopes that he can rediscover his form. At this point, it may be best for both sides if the Blue Jays cut the former All-Star loose.