Yardbarker
x
Yankees’ embarrassing comeback attempt marks an MLB-first
New York Yankees second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. (13) reacts after flying out with the bases loaded during the ninth inning of Game 1 of the wild-card round of the 2025 MLB playoffs against the Boston Red Sox at Yankee Stadium. Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Yankees’ embarrassing comeback attempt vs. Red Sox marks an MLB-first

The New York Yankees are great at putting runners on bases, it’s scoring them that poses a problem. The Yankees offensive stagnation was on full display in Tuesday’s American League wild-card game.

Paul Goldschmidt and Aaron Judge started the Yankees’ half of the first with back-to-back base hits against Boston Red Sox starter Garrett Crochet. However, nothing would come of it.

Crochet and Yankees starter Max Fried dueled in what had been a near-spotless rubber match, the lone run coming off an Anthony Volpe home run. After Fried departed in the seventh inning, struggling reliever Luke Weaver took the ball and gave up two runs without recording an out. David Bednar would allow another run on an Alex Bregman double in the ninth. In the bottom half, New York would make history against its former closer Aroldis Chapman, but not the good kind. 

Yankees fail to capitalize on the game's largest possible opportunity at the last second 

In another last-minute comeback attempt, the Yankees managed to load the bases in the bottom of the ninth inning. Goldschmidt and Judge singled again, this time followed by a base hit from Cody Bellinger. With the bases loaded and no outs, the Yankees failed to score a single run, finishing the game with a 3-1 loss.

According to Opta Stats, it is the first time in postseason history where a team loaded the bases with no outs in the bottom of the ninth and failed to score a run, losing the game. 

For the Yankees, such a feat isn’t a very rare event. In fact, it is an elusive magic trick they rehearsed numerous times this year alone. Against elite arms such as Crochet and Chapman, the only two pitchers the Red Sox used on Tuesday, it isn’t too puzzling to imagine the Yankees struggling. But with a few prime opportunities on their doorstep, it still boggles the mind that such a potent lineup failed to inflict even minimal damage.

On the day, Judge, Goldschmidt and Volpe combined to go 6-for-11. The rest of the Yankees lineup went 1-for-22. 

The Yankees will face elimination on Wednesday in Game 2. Should the Red Sox prevail on Wednesday, or Thursday, the Yankees will have lost the last four postseason matches against their prominent rivals, having lost in the 2004 ALCS, the 2018 ALDS and the 2021 wild-card game. 

Jacob Mountz

Jacob Mountz is an avid baseball enthusiast and New York Yankee fanatic. His work covering the MLB has been featured on Yardbarker, Athlon Sports, FanSided, House That Hank Built and Medium. Jacob thoroughly enjoys Aaron Judge's moonshots and cheeseburgers of all sizes. 

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!