Hours after the Cleveland Browns (1-3) confirmed on Wednesday that they will start rookie quarterback Dillon Gabriel over veteran Joe Flacco for this coming Sunday's game against the Minnesota Vikings (2-2), first-year pro Shedeur Sanders mouthed silent answers to reporters' questions inside the Cleveland locker room.
During Thursday's edition of the ESPN "Get Up" program, former NFL quarterback and current analyst Dan Orlovsky was critical of Sanders and sent a message to the rookie regarding that decision.
"I actually don’t think there is a time and place to act like that as a quarterback," Orlovsky explained, per Chris Rosvoglou of The Spun. "Everything you do when you’re a quarterback — I don’t care if you’re first, second or third — is a job interview. My question to Shedeur would be: Are you helping yourself in your own building? Did that 30 or 40 seconds help you in your own building when it comes to what they think you can be in the future? And did you help yourself outside of the building? There’s 64 jobs, essentially, at that spot in the NFL. Did that 30 or 40 seconds help your future there or elsewhere?"
On Wednesday afternoon, ESPN's Adam Schefter revealed that Sanders' mime act "was in response to ESPN analyst Rex Ryan criticizing the rookie QB earlier this week." Specifically, Ryan said during Monday's episode of "Get Up" that Sanders "should be embarrassed" he's third on the Cleveland depth chart this fall. Ryan also hinted he has been told by somebody within the Browns that Sanders hasn't been working hard enough behind the scenes.
Later on Thursday morning, former NFL safety and current ESPN analyst Ryan Clark pointed out that Sanders is in a unique position as a third-string quarterback who generates headlines and receives attention from media members. Flacco is on track to serve as Gabriel's primary backup versus the Vikings at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in London.
Ryan Clark believes Shedeur Sanders is in "the most unique situation we've ever seen a young quarterback be in. There are no other third quarterbacks on the depth chart getting interviewed every day" pic.twitter.com/IrV9BsaXTO
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) October 2, 2025
Dan Labbe of the "Orange and Brown Talk Podcast" referred to Sanders' antics as "one of the most bizarre things that has happened there when I’ve been in [the Browns'] building." Labbe also said that Sanders showed on Wednesday he is "clearly not mature enough to be a starting quarterback in the NFL."
For whatever reasons, those running the Browns agree that Sanders isn't ready to face a live defense in a meaningful game. There's no indication that will change anytime soon, even if Gabriel plays poorly against Minnesota's defense.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!