
There's probably nothing worse in sports than being the general manager to trade a superstar.
In hockey, in particular, where GMs typically covet average NHL players like Gollum and the One Ring, it must be particularly difficult to finally acknowledge defeat and trade a superstar.
In Vancouver, it must be torture — especially when you consider their fans have watched the last two genuinely great Canucks teams make the Stanley Cup Finals and lose in seven games to Original Six franchises.
Vancouver has a president of hockey operations in Jim Rutherford who has been clear that he's not interested in a tear-it-all-down rebuild. After being forced into trading forward J.T. Miller last season, Rutherford immediately used the draft-pick asset acquired in that trade to bring in defenseman Marcus Pettersson. Vancouver couldn't afford to engage in a rebuild that chased star players out of the organization following years of prior wheel-spinning.
Except, right now, the Canucks don't feel anywhere close to being either the 2010-11 or 1993-94 teams. They don't feel particularly close to being the team two years ago that took Edmonton to seven games in the second round of the playoffs.
The world just feels right when we have the Quinn Hughes staring into the void before a period look pic.twitter.com/pWjbYppKeQ
— Wyatt Arndt (@TheStanchion) November 4, 2025
They're 7-8-0 through 15 games, 22nd in goals for, 25th in goals against, 32nd by Hockey-Reference's season strength of schedule calculator with the fourth-most-difficult remaining strength of schedule per the website Tankathon, have not won a game in regulation since Oct. 19 and have a once-superstar centerman in Elias Pettersson whose game is inexplicably off.
Per Natural Stat Trick, Vancouver is 28th in shot-attempt percentage, 29th in shots-on-goal percentage, 27th in expected goals percentage and 23rd in high danger chance percentage. All those numbers are at five-on-five. On special teams, the Canucks are 19th in power-play percentage (19.2 percent) and 31st in penalty-killing percentage (68 percent).
If not for the red-hot start to the season by 30-year-old journeyman Kiefer Sherwood, whose nine goals in 15 games would put him on pace to break his career high of 19 goals (set last season) with 50 games left to play, Vancouver's record might be even worse.
Devils fans painted the ice with a popular message for NJD & Quinn Hughes
— B/R Open Ice (@BR_OpenIce) May 11, 2025
(via: @joshlangerr) pic.twitter.com/5NZA2D6VrQ
Well, the good news is goaltender Thatcher Demko has been pretty good, sporting a .911 save percentage. Meanwhile, Hughes hasn't looked like himself. The Canucks have been outscored with Hughes on the ice at five-on-five, an oddity since Vancouver is plus-74 with Hughes on the ice at five-on-five in the past four seasons. They're minus-three (11-8) in 11 games with Hughes on-ice.
It's entirely possible that Hughes, who missed four games with an injury, is playing hurt. Vancouver, however, has really not played particularly well in any facet of the game under new head coach Adam Foote. Things, potentially, could get worse. What happens then?
Rutherford has already implied that the 2027 trade deadline is the team's working deadline for a decision. He also implied that Quinn Hughes may want to join his brothers in New Jersey.
Every day the Canucks wait to deal him, they lose value. Trading him now widens the field. Teams competing for a Stanley Cup will be more willing to spend the exorbitant cost to acquire Hughes knowing they can take at least two shots at the Stanley Cup with Hughes. It's the only way Vancouver will recoup any actual premium prospects to shorten the length of any potential on-ice losing that might accompany the trade. The Canucks certainly aren't playing well with him.
Go ahead. Rip off that Band-Aid, Vancouver.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!