
Head coach Ryan Day's sudden play-calling switcheroo has cost the Ohio State Buckeyes a national championship.
Before the Buckeyes faced the Miami Hurricanes in the College Football Playoff quarterfinals at the Cotton Bowl on New Year's Eve, Day assumed play-calling duties for the first time since the 2023 season. Offensive coordinator/wide receivers coach Brian Hartline has called plays this season, but he's set to become the next HC for the South Florida Bulls in 2026. So, the coach wanted to lighten his assistant's workload.
"We wanted to take [playcalling] off of Brian's plate because he's got so much going on with what he's trying to do," Day said Dec. 22, per ESPN's Jake Trotter. "Ultimately, it will be my decision what calls go into the game."
ESPN analyst/former Alabama Crimson Tide HC Nick Saban thought the sudden coaching change wouldn't give the Buckeyes any problems against Miami. However, the seven-time national champion was proved wrong.
Day's rust as a play-caller showed in the first half against the Hurricanes. The Buckeyes were held to -3 rushing yards in the first half and committed a costly turnover early in the second quarter. Buckeyes quarterback Julian Sayin threw an interception to defensive back Keionte Scott, who returned it for a 72-yard touchdown. That gave the Hurricanes a 14-0 lead heading into halftime.
MIAMI PICK-SIX ON JULIAN SAYIN pic.twitter.com/L4EOq0KAiB
— SportsCenter (@SportsCenter) January 1, 2026
Day rediscovered some of his offensive wizardry in the second half when he started targeting star wide receiver Jeremiah Smith more. The WR, who finished with seven receptions for 157 yards and one TD catch, caught a 14-yard TD pass early in the fourth quarter, cutting the deficit to 17-14.
JULIAN SAYIN TO JEREMIAH SMITH
— ESPN (@espn) January 1, 2026
We've got a one-score game on ESPN and the ESPN App pic.twitter.com/YXW1RlGCBP
The tired Buckeyes defense, however, broke down. Miami QB Carson Beck engineered a 10-play, 70-yard drive, which ended with running back CharMar Brown plunging in for a five-yard TD. Sayin subsequently tossed an interception to defensive back Jakobe Thomas, sealing a 24-14 Hurricanes upset.
Now, many of the Buckeyes stars wilted on the big stage. Surprisingly, Beck made fewer mistakes than 2025 Heisman finalist Sayin. The Ohio State QB finished 22-of-35 passing for 287 yards, one TD pass and two interceptions. The Miami QB, meanwhile, completed 19-of-26 passes for 138 yards and one TD.
But the loss ultimately falls on Day's decision. He shouldn't have made the switch this late in the season against one of the top defenses in college football. Entering the Cotton Bowl, Miami ranked fourth in the FBS in points allowed (13.8).
Day hasn't named a play-caller for the 2026 season. If he does it again, he clearly needs a refresher after his performance in the Cotton Bowl. And should he even consider it after this offensive disaster? Many Buckeyes fans would say no.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!