
The Carolina Panthers missed another chance to clinch the NFC South on Saturday night by dropping a tough 16-14 decision to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. There is plenty of blame to go around for the loss, including a terrible first-quarter performance and a questionable flea-flicker play that did not work as planned.
They also have plenty of reason to be livid with referee Brad Allen and his crew.
Allen's crew is no stranger to controversial calls, and Saturday's game had more than a few.
Some of the more blatant missed calls were a missed face-mask call when Tampa Bay's SirVocea Dennis ripped the helmet off of Carolina's Tommy Tremble with no flag.
Along those same lines there was also a missed late-hit out of bounds in the fourth quarter that could have given the Panthers an additional 15 yards.
One of the most bizarre missed calls was a premature whistle that stopped a play when Carolina quarterback Bryce Young threw the ball backwards to running back Rico Dowdle. When the ball hit the ground, Dowdle picked the ball up with room to run, only to have the side judge call the pass incomplete and the play whistled. They eventually corrected it to a backwards pass after the fact, but the damage was already done by stopping the play.
The two more "judgment" calls that should have Carolina its heads were two pass interference calls that impacted both sides of the ball.
The first was an offensive pass interference call against Tetairoa McMillan that negated a 38-yard play that would have Carolina set up deep in Tampa Bay territory.
ESPN rules analyst Mike Chase agreed with the call (as TV rules analysts typically do despite evidence to the contrary), but the announcing crew was not having any of it.
Dan Orlovsky: "That's just not offensive pass interference."
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) January 4, 2026
ESPN rules analyst Mike Chase: "He shoves him out of the play to begin with. That's why he's so wide open."
Chris Fowler: "So you support the call?"
Chase: "I do. I do." ️ #NFL pic.twitter.com/C7ahtUjZsS
That turned out to be a huge call as Carolina did not score on that possession. A field goal would have at least been in the cards without it being flagged. In a game that was decided by two points, that is significant.
Later in the quarter, Carolina was flagged for defensive pass interference when it appeared safety Nick Scott and tight end Cade Otton simply got their feet tangled up, which is not typically flagged for defensive pass interference.
Dan Orlovsky: "I just think it's guys competing down the field... I just don't think that's PI."
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) January 4, 2026
Rules analyst Mike Chase: "He's just not playing the ball there... Once he turns his back like that, he puts himself in harm's way. That's a tough one. I'll give you that, Dan." pic.twitter.com/6ZtJ1LqAGf
Tampa Bay ended up kicking a field goal on that drive to take a 16-7 lead. It was another pivotal call and play.
Panthers head coach Dave Canales refused to put the blame for the result on officials and instead focused on the missed opportunities by his team and himself. That is the professional approach. Also the best approach to avoid a fine. He and his team had a job to do and ultimately did not get it done.
Him taking the high road, and putting the blame on his team for not performing, does not change the fact Allen's crew also had a job to do in this game. They were not good at it. It also may have played a big outcome in the result of the game.
Now Carolina and Tampa Bay have to wait for the winner of Sunday's Atlanta Falcons-New Orleans Saints game to see who wins the NFC South. If the Falcons win, Carolina takes the division in a three-way tiebreaker. If New Orleans wins, Tampa Bay wins the division. Either way, an 8-9 team will be hosting a playoff game next week.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!