
In their first three spring training games, the New York Yankees gave us a sample of their unpredictable brand of baseball. The first game of spring saw them lose 2-0 in shutout fashion to the Baltimore Orioles. The next game, they crushed the Detroit Tigers 20-3. In their third game on Sunday, the Yankees fell 6-4 to the New York Mets, a reminder of how their potent offense can jump back to life from dormancy and vice versa.
While the offseason lull may have been drab by the standards of New York’s fan base, there is excitement building for the “run-it-back Yankees.” Let’s view three storylines to keep an eye on as Opening Day approaches.
This season, the Yankees will likely have two Aaron Judges in the outfield. It didn’t take long for Jones (Yankees no. 4 prospect), dubbed the “left-handed Aaron Judge,” to make a strong statement. In his first glimpse of 2026 action on Saturday, Jones took Tigers’ righty Keider Montero deep, launching a 95-mph fastball into the parking lot.
After years of lackluster performances that had many questioning his major-league viability, the Yankee phenom broke out last season, hitting .274/.362/.571 with 35 home runs in 438 at-bats. This latest long ball was an indication that he can handle pitching on the major-league level; however, it did come with a familiar drawback. Jones went 1-for-3 with two strikeouts on the day, reminding us that strikeouts are still a major hurdle to his success.
.@Yankees prospect Spencer Jones SMOKES his first #SpringTraining home run! pic.twitter.com/qMrKlV6aUW
— MLB (@MLB) February 21, 2026
While Gerrit Cole’s recovery progress has dominated the recent Yankee headlines, the team’s prospective starters have refused to take a back seat to their ace. After throwing close to 103 mph in a duel with Judge, Carlos Lagrange (Yankees no. 2 prospect) lit up the radar gun against the Tigers on Saturday, touching 102.4. Lagrange finished the day after 2.2 innings, giving up one earned run on a Corey Julks solo blast. He would end the day allowing three hits and two walks while garnering two strikeouts.
In the eighth inning, Brock Selvidge (Yankees no. 10 prospect) came in to deliver a brilliant outing, striking out four in just two innings of work, allowing only one walk. Selvidge isn’t expected to make his debut this year, but a combination of strong performance and the uncertainty of the Yankees’ pitching staff could alter that timeline as it did with Cam Schlittler.
These performances followed a strong outing from Elmer Rodriguez (Yankees no. 3 prospect) on Friday. Rodriguez pitched three shutout innings against the Baltimore Orioles, allowing three hits and recording one strikeout.
Carlos Lagrange is Disgusting.
— Rob Friedman (@PitchingNinja) February 21, 2026
3 Pitch Sequence:
101.8 mph ⛽️
83.2 mph Slider (with 20 inches Horizontal Break)
102.4 mph ⛽️ pic.twitter.com/np5X73715m
McMahon has generated buzz lately for two reasons. First, there is the matter of his new batting stance. This season, the Yankees are working to shorten his stance at the plate to cut down on strikeouts. McMahon struck out a total of 189 times last year. That’s a career-high 35.2 percent of the time for McMahon. If he can make more contact, there is a lot to be excited about.
McMahon’s average exit velocity (93.3 mph) ranks him in the elite 95th percentile according to Baseball Savant. His hard-hit rate (50.5 percent) lands him in the 89th percentile.
The second reason McMahon has been in the news is that the Yankees are looking to give him reps at shortstop. Why move an elite third baseman to short? We don’t yet know, making this a story to keep an eye on. McMahon is 1-3 with a double in one appearance this spring.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!