Where does Lou Holtz rank all-time among Notre Dame coaches?

The best coaches in Notre Dame history

In Notre Dame's illustrious history, six coaches have been named to the College Football Hall of Fame, five have won national championships and another coach entirely from that group has the most wins in program history. So, finding the best coach is not an easy task.

Holtz posted a 100-30-2 record during his time in South Bend. That included one national championship, as well as five wins in what are considered New Year's Six bowls today. 

Since Holtz finished coaching, Notre Dame hasn't managed a national championship. Brian Kelly came close, going to a BCS Championship Game and the College Football Playoff twice. He also managed to win the most games in program history, at 113. However, that's with a longer yearly schedule and his lack of postseason success that looms large. 

The most famous coach in Notre Dame history is, of course, Knute Rockne. He took over in 1918 and would lead the program until his early death in 1930. During that time, he went 105-12-5. That's the second most wins and the best winning percentage of a coach with more than 15 games at the school. He also won three national championships. 

Perhaps more importantly, he helped build the legend of the Notre Dame program. That included his "Win One For The Gipper" speech. It included recruiting immigrants, like himself, and playing a national schedule as an Independent. That helped to build a national fanbase and set up all future coaches for success.

One coach who arguably had more on-field success was Frank Leahy. A Rockne disciple, Leahy missed time coaching to fight in World War II, but still went 87-11-9 with four national championships, re-establishing the Notre Dame brand in football.

The other two coaches with national championships were Ara Parseghian, with two and Dan Devine with one. Parseghian went 95-17-4 in 11 seasons. Devine went 53-16-1 in six seasons.

Jesse Harper, incidentally, is the final Notre Dame coach to make the Hall of Fame. He holds a 34-5-1 all-time record and coached before Rockne.  

Where does Lou Holtz rank among those coaches?

Holtz is going to be honored as one of the elite coaches in Notre Dame history. That's well deserved. However, he wasn't able to pass Rockne, who won more games and national championships while building the program. 

Holtz also sits behind Leahy, who found massive success that kept Notre Dame from being a flash in the pan during the early days of college football. 

The big debate is whether Holtz should be third or fourth, behind or in front of Parseghian. Ultimately, it's fourth. One more national championship and a better winning percentage were too much to overcome. Still, fourth gets Holtz on the Mount Rushmore of Notre Dame coaches.