x
History shows Magic's Game 1 win might not be significant
Orlando Magic guard Jalen Suggs (4) and forward Paolo Banchero (5) talk during a timeout in the first half against the Detroit Pistons during a first round game of the 2026 NBA Playoffs at Little Caesars Arena. Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images

History shows Magic's Game 1 win might not be significant

The eight seed Orlando Magic upset the top-seeded Detroit Pistons in their series opener Sunday, 112-101. It was an impressive victory but also fits Orlando's recent history of taking a single game in a first-round series.

The Magic haven't won a playoff series since 2010, when they lost in the Eastern Conference Finals. Since then, they've lost all six of their first-round series, and won a single game in four of them.

Orlando Magic are better than a normal eight seed

The Magic finished in eighth place in the East with a 45-37 record, though they were only one game worse than the fifth-seeded Toronto Raptors. Star forward Franz Wagner missed 48 games, which may well have been the difference between a play-in appearance and a fifth-place finish.

Sunday, they dominated the Pistons near the basket, outscoring them 54 to 43 on points in the paint. All five Magic starters scored 16 points or more, with Paolo Banchero leading the way with 23. Wagner and Banchero both shot over 50 percent while the Magic held Pistons All-Star center Jalen Duren to only eight points.

It's the second strong game for the Magic after they torched the Charlotte Hornets in the final play-in game Friday. The Magic's two games last week didn't give them as much rest as the Pistons' full week off, but perhaps the time off left the Pistons rusty in their playoff opener.

Game 2 is crucial for the Detroit Pistons

Normally, the Pistons would be a huge favorite in Game 2, on Wednesday. They have the best record in the Eastern Conference, All-NBA guard Cade Cunningham (39 points Sunday) and home-court advantage. But the Pistons haven't won a playoff game at home since May 2008, a streak of 11 straight losses in front of their home fans.

Granted, the Pistons are 2-19 overall, so they aren't all that much better away from home. Their two road wins came last season in New York while the Pistons dropped all three games in Detroit.

It's not uncommon for an underdog to steal the first game of a series in the NBA, especially against a relatively inexperienced team like the Pistons. Orlando won Game 1 against the Toronto Raptors in 2019, and Toronto went on to win the title. The Magic beat the top-seeded Milwaukee Bucks in Game 1 in 2020, then lost the next four games by an average of 14.5 points.

The Magic even got a win against the top-seeded Boston Celtics last playoffs, when Wagner and Banchero combined for 61 points in Game 3. Orlando should be proud of Sunday's effort but there's a reason the Pistons won 15 more games than them this season.

So the Pistons have no reason to panic. Unless they lose Game 2 at home as well. That could be a worry after Sunday's sluggish performance, but based on Orlando's playoff history, it's very possible that Sunday will end up a footnote in the Pistons' eventual "gentleman's sweep."

Sean Keane

Sean Keane is a sportswriter and a comedian based in Oakland, California, with experience covering the NBA, MLB, NFL and Ice Cube’s three-on-three basketball league, The Big 3. He’s written for Comedy Central’s “Another Period,” ESPN the Magazine, and Audible. com

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!