
Nothing is going right for the Pittsburgh Penguins in their first-round playoff series against the Philadelphia Flyers, and things really reached a meltdown on Wednesday in a 5-2 loss to put them in a 3-0 series deficit. One of the plays from that game that has them most irritated is an embellishment penalty call on captain Sidney Crosby.
It happened in the first period as the two teams were in the process of lining up for a faceoff.
As Crosby was positioned for the draw, Flyers forward Garnet Hathaway was skating and carelessly twirling his stick around, resulting in it clipping Crosby in the face.
Crosby immediately dropped to the ice and remained there for a few seconds as the officials tried to gather what happened.
Hathaway high sticked Crosby before the draw, but Crosby was ALSO penalized for embellishment, we play 4 on 4.... pic.twitter.com/QcsGi9wg7J
— B/R Open Ice (@BR_OpenIce) April 22, 2026
In the end, Hathaway was called for high-sticking, but things were evened up as Crosby was also called for embellishment.
Flyers fans have long criticized Crosby for diving and embellishing, so him actually getting called for it in a playoff game, in Philadelphia, was like throwing a bucket of chum into shark-infested waters.
The Penguins strongly disagreed with the call after the game, with head coach Dan Muse coming to Crosby's defense and pointing out that this is the first time in his two-decade-plus career he has been called for embellishment.
PIT coach Muse: “We don't have a single embellishment all year. Sidney Crosby doesn't have an embellishment in 21 seasons. Stick in his face, they take both of them. I disagree on that strongly. We didn't come into this series to start [embellishing] now. Sid doesn't embellish.”
— Greg Wyshynski (@wyshynski) April 23, 2026
The irony of this is that Hathaway, the player who initiated the sequence with the careless high-stick, has actually been fined by the NHL for embellishment in the past, meaning the league has flagged him for multiple embellishments. (Players get a warning for their first embellishment, and then get fined for the second.)
Your opinion on the calls here is largely going to come down to what side of Pennsylvania you reside in and what your rooting interests are. It is clearly a penalty. Crosby took his time getting up and remained on the ice for a bit to make sure everybody knew he was hit. But if he does not do that, does the high-sticking penalty even get noticed?
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!