
Another season of the Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl era has come and gone for the Edmonton Oilers, and it once again ended without a Stanley Cup. This time it came to an end in the first round with an emphatic six-game series loss to the Anaheim Ducks, who won the clinching game on Thursday night by a 5-2 margin.
All season, there was a massive concern over the Oilers' goaltending situation and whether or not it would be good enough to help them win in the playoffs. It has been a problem for years with no solution having been found.
While it did, in fact, end up being a problem, there was an even bigger problem that we did not really account for with the Oilers.
They simply were not a good enough team regardless of who the goalie was.
And everybody knew it.
Including their best player.
Following Thursday's elimination, McDavid made a devastatingly pointed comment in saying the Oilers were an average team with high expectations.
Connor McDavid says the #oilers were an "average team with high expectations":
— Chris Johnston (@reporterchris) May 1, 2026
"That's been the whole year. We've been searching for consistency the whole year. Obviously we didn't find it in the playoffs."
Even with that he might have been giving them too much credit.
There is plenty of blame to go around for this early exit, and nobody is immune from it.
McDavid and Draisaitl had a terrible series, and while injuries certainly played a role in both of their performances, the harsh reality is they just simply were not good enough.
What made that such a devastating development is the Oilers never had the depth to make up for a less-than-dominant showing by their two best players. This supporting cast performed worse than just about any supporting cast the two superstars have had in Edmonton, and there was never anybody to help pick up the slack in the event one, or both, struggled.
During the regular season the Oilers were outscored by a 55-86 margin during 5-on-5 play when neither player was on the ice, while also getting badly out-chanced and out-played. They managed only a 48.1% expected goal share in those minutes to go with the lopsided goal differential.
When you combine the lack of depth with the fact that McDavid and Draisaitl were way off their games, the end result was absolutely brutal for the Oilers. They not only lost to a young, upstart Ducks team, but they were mostly dominated by them. Anaheim was nearly unstoppable on the power play and completely dictated the pace of play during even-strength situations.
All of it is just a complete organizational failure, from the front office in assembling such a poor roster, to the coaching staff for looking completely in over its head the entire series, to the players on the ice simply not performing.
This past offseason, McDavid did the Oilers a huge favor when he signed a two-year contract extension for the exact same salary-cap hit as his previous contract. Given the rapidly rising salary cap over the next few seasons, it was essentially a pay decrease for McDavid (and a significant one) as it relates to the cap. That should give the Oilers some extra cap flexibility to build around him.
The fact it was only a two-year deal should have been a concern. It was basically him putting the Oilers on the clock to say they had two years to prove they can build a winner around him.
General manager Stan Bowman has not shown any indication he is capable of that. That is only going to turn up the heat even more going into this offseason. The clock is ticking.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!