
The Western Conference Finals were shaping up to be a battle between two-time NBA MVP Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Defensive Player of the Year Victor Wembanyama. Instead, Game 1 was a duel between Wemby and Alex Caruso of the Oklahoma City Thunder.
Wembanyama had a 41-point, 24-rebound performance and played 49 minutes as the San Antonio Spurs beat the Thunder in two overtimes, 122-115. He spoiled a career night from Caruso, who made eight three-pointers and scored 31 points, along with two steals and two blocks, but it wasn't enough.
Wembanyama's previous career high was 43 minutes. He never played more than 40 minutes in a game during a season he averaged 29.2 MPG. That didn't stop him from tying the game late in the first overtime, then making huge plays in double-overtime, even after a game spent battling Chet Holmgren, Caruso and the strong Thunder defenders.
In double overtime, Wembanyama scored nine of the Spurs' 21 points, grabbed four rebounds and slammed the door on the Thunder by blocking Jalen Williams in the final seconds. Perhaps his most satisfying play came when he put the Spurs up by four by dunking on longtime rival Chat Holmgren and getting the and-one.
WEMBY WITH THE AND-1.
— NBA (@NBA) May 19, 2026
SPURS BACK UP 3. 1:01 LEFT IN 2OT ON NBC/PEACOCK. pic.twitter.com/6ZXFS7b1yG
Caruso deflected the entry pass and Holmgren blocked Wembanyama's potential game-winner at the end of regulation to force overtime. In the first overtime, Caruso knocked away a lob pass at the rim to keep the game tied. In the second OT, Wemby made sure it didn't come down to the final play.
CHET HOLMGREN PULLS OFF THE INSANE BLOCK ON WEMBY TO SEND GAME 1 TO OVERTIME!
— NBA on NBC and Peacock (@NBAonNBC) May 19, 2026
NBC and Peacock pic.twitter.com/e9qaPicQM5
Alex Caruso comes up with the GREAT defensive play to send us to DOUBLE OVERTIME!
— NBA on NBC and Peacock (@NBAonNBC) May 19, 2026
NBC and Peacock pic.twitter.com/n2iQVqYeCD
Caruso's defense was world-class in the win, whether he was defending Wembanyama while giving up 11 inches of height, or helping the Thunder force 21 Spurs turnovers. Thunder coach Mark Daigneault sensed he needed Caruso early, bringing him off the bench after only 2:36 had elapsed.
What he couldn't have anticipated was Caruso pacing the Thunder with 31 points and single-handedly keeping his team competitive from behind the arc, shooting 8-for-14 as the other Thunder players went 9-for-31. Caruso was often matched up on Wembanyama on both offense and defense, exploiting Wemby helping off him to hit threes and sometimes beating Wembanyama to the rim.
Alex Caruso went right at Wemby on offense AND defense. pic.twitter.com/u9UkLTZx0H
— NBA on NBC and Peacock (@NBAonNBC) May 19, 2026
Though watching Caruso go nuts from behind the arc might have inspired a game-saving shot from Wemby. After Caruso hit a three-pointer in overtime and Wembanyama couldn't score on an offensive rebound and tip-in, Wemby sank his lone three of the night from well behind the arc.
WEMBY PULLS UP FROM THE PARKING LOT TO TIE THE GAME! WHAT A SHOT!!!
— NBA on NBC and Peacock (@NBAonNBC) May 19, 2026
NBC and Peacock pic.twitter.com/4QV5W1N0Gv
Wembanyama and the Spurs stole Game 1 and home-court advantage. It's up to SGA, Holmgren and, yes, Caruso to retake control of the series against an unreal 22-year-old center.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!