
CHICAGO, IL — As the 2026 FIFA World Cup looms, the questions surrounding the U. S. Men's National Team are rote and familiar.
Will Mauricio Pochettino play with a back three or a back four, and in what phase of play? Will he sink Weston McKennie or Malik Tillman into a deeper midfield role, or will he exclusively rely on Tyler Adams, Sebastian Berhalter and Cristian Roldan? Is Alex Freeman a right-sided center back, a right fullback or a right wing back? Is Sergino Dest a right wing back or a right winger? And please, in the name of all that is holy, will Chris Richards be available to start against Paraguay?
These questions share themes: tactics, formation, execution. They are base-level, hands-on operational asks posed by a distant media trying to suss out, and eventually transcribe, how the USMNT actually pulls itself together for big games.
What these questions are not, though, are accurate reflections of how the USMNT understands its own tactics. Make no mistake: the American soccer ecosystem might be desperate to figure out Dest's technical positional title, but the USMNT isn't. It's so locked in on its tactical approach that it's moved past tactics altogether in service of focusing on mentality and resilience.
USMNT midfielder Tyler Adams was quick to point that out after his team's 2-1 loss to Germany in its World Cup send-off match. When asked about the team's tactics in the lead-up to the World Cup, Adams just shrugged.
"I don’t think any of these tune-up games are about tactics, you know what I mean?" he said. "We’ve trained together, we’ve played together, we’ve worked under Mauricio for a year and a half now. We understand the tactics.
"It has to be about the mentality."
Beautiful, concise and clear. Take Adams's word for it, because he knows better than anyone: the USMNT has its tactics locked down. It's the rest of the American soccer ecosystem that's confused.
But where does that confusion come from? It's a fascinating question and one that points to the cross-cultural exchange at the heart of the game of soccer.
For most Americans, raised on a left-brained sports diet of plays and statistics, soccer formations are a solid: a game board of eleven specific, rigid, unchanging positions who interact with one another in set ways. A center back is someone who defends the goal; a winger is someone who charges down the flank. That's it. Sure, their responsibilities might evolve depending on whether or not their team has the ball, but they're on the field to do a specific job—and that's why questions like "is Dest a wing back or a winger" carry so much weight for American fans. It's how they evaluate his game-day performance.
For Pochettino and his charges, though, soccer formations are a gas. They are expansive, undefined and ever-changing, and they matter far less than the collective mentality of the eleven players on the field. Want to know if Dest is a wing back or a winger? Good luck finding out, because no one on the USMNT can agree on it. Dest categorized himself as a wing back before the Germany game; a few minutes later, his teammate Tim Ream called him a winger without hesitation. They didn't diverge because they don't understand; they diverged because Dest's positional title isn't all that relevant to them. His work is. His mentality is.
As the USMNT prepares for its World Cup debut against Paraguay, then, clever fans will pull away from the nitty-gritty tactical questions posed by the media and start wondering about the team's mentality instead. It's what stars like Adams have already started doing, and it's the best way to truly understand this team.
The USMNT will open its World Cup against Paraguay on Friday, Jun. 12 in Inglewood, C.A.
All quotes obtained firsthand unless otherwise noted.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!