x
Oilers must end Mike Babcock pursuit before they do more damage
Mike Babcock. The Columbus Dispatch-USA TODAY NETWORK

Oilers need to end their pursuit of Mike Babcock before they do even more damage

The Edmonton Oilers have made it pretty clear they are desperate to win a Stanley Cup while they still have superstars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl on their roster. 

They are becoming shamelessly desperate. So shamelessly desperate, they are willing to do anything and hire anybody, in an effort to win. Even if it comes with significant PR hits and a loss of anything resembling respect. 

What makes it all even worse is that they are not only selling out their dignity, but they aren't even pursuing the best possible people for the jobs to get them closer to winning. That will especially be true if they actually find a way to hire Mike Babcock

It should never get to that point. They need to end this insanity as soon as possible, not only to save their own image but also to actually find a better coach. There have to be better coaches available to them. 

The Oilers are embarrassing themselves with the pursuit of Mike Babcock

The most obvious issue with the Babcock pursuit is all of the baggage that comes with him. And it is a lot. Department stores don't have this much baggage in stock. 

The list of complaints against him for his treatment of players is extensive, and somehow still growing, even though he has not actually coached in several years.

When he coached the Detroit Red Wings, his treatment of Johan Franzen drove the Swedish winger to a mental breakdown on the bench and in the locker room, a story that was backed up by Chris Chelios. Franzen called Babcock the worst person he has ever met. 

His treatment of Mitch Marner with the Toronto Maple Leafs, where he forced the rookie to rank his teammate's work ethics, and then shared those rankings with the team, was a big part of what forced him out. 

When he was briefly hired by the Columbus Blue Jackets, his attempt to check players' personal phones and photos was seen as so out of bounds and over the line that he resigned before even making it to training camp.

In terms of being a boss and a leader, he's not a good person. Now that Edmonton is pursuing Babcock, the NHLPA initiated an investigation into his conduct in Columbus, and it seems it is going to produce even more red flags. 

NHL insider Frank Seravalli reported on Wednesday that the NHLPA is in receipt of "significant" additional claims against Babcock during his time in Columbus. Even more concerning, he also reported that the phone saga was not the incident that resulted in his resignation, but another allegation that was never made public.

A good rule of thumb should be that if your head-coaching search prompts a player's union investigation, you might want to consider other options. 

The subplot to all of this is the reality that Babcock might not even be a good coach anymore. Objectively speaking, he isn't. His only Stanley Cup win came in 2008. That is 18 years ago. He has coached a team into the second round just one time since 2011, and zero times since 2013. It has been more than a decade and a half since one of his teams had real postseason success.

His Detroit teams late in his Red Wings tenures underachieved. All of his Toronto teams underachieved. What is the appeal here? Why are you so interested in this guy that you are willing to put aside the baggage to hire him? Are you that desperate? Or is it just sheer incompetence? Probably an ugly mix of both.

The Oilers already took a huge PR hit when they hired general manager Stan Bowman to run their team following his resignation from the Chicago Blackhawks over the 2009 sexual abuse cover-up. Like Babcock, Bowman was not only an executive who came with serious baggage, but he also had nearly a decade's worth of poor management leading to the Blackhawks decline on his resume.

Nearly every move he's made since taking the Oilers job has been wrong or a failure. They might be on the verge of repeating that same mistake. 

Adam Gretz

Adam Gretz is a freelance writer based in Pittsburgh. He covers the NHL, NFL, MLB and NBA. Baseball is his favorite sport -- he is nearly halfway through his goal of seeing a game in every MLB ballpark. Catch him on X @AGretz

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!