
Some NBA players perform better in a contract year. That hasn't been the case for Josh Hart.
The New York Knicks benched Hart for nearly all of the fourth quarter and overtime in their 112-108 win over the Toronto Raptors. It's the second game where coach Mike Brown has sat Hart in crunch time and could be a bad sign for his Knicks' future.
Hart went scoreless in Sunday's overtime win, as he did in Friday's loss to the Indiana Pacers. For the season, Hart's shooting has severely declined, dropping from 41.3 percent to 29.5 percent on three-pointers and from 50.8 percent to 36.2 percent overall. His scoring has dropped from 12 points per game to 7.3.
He's been slowed by injuries to his calf and his ankle, and missed one game due to an illness. Maybe due to his physical struggles, Hart is taking over 60 percent of his shots behind the three-point line, and not doing well. After Friday's game, Hart admitted to reporters he was "not in a good head space," either due to the benching or his struggles to put up points.
What could be creating his "head space" issues is the uncertainty about his future in New York. Immediately after Hart and the Knicks triumphed in the NBA Finals, owner James Dolan announced the team's unwillingness to exceed the second salary tax apron and before the season, the team paused all extension talks.
That's crucial to Hart's future. Knicks hold a $22.4 million option on Hart for next season, meaning he could find himself unemployed just a year after helping the Knicks win an NBA title. Not only might he not get an extension, but the team could also trade or cut Hart to save money.
Hart is vitally important to the Knicks when he's playing well. He's a tenacious defender and an excellent rebounder for his 6-foot-5 height, and he can operate as a secondary ball handler and distributor.
But when his shot isn't falling, that can bog down the Knicks offense. It's hard for Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns to find space when defenders can sag off Hart and dare him to shoot. During the 2025 Eastern Conference Finals, former Knicks coach Tom Thibodeau took Hart out of the starting lineup when he struggled.
Still, Hart played more than 34 minutes in the first three games he came off the bench, then returned to start 52 games last season. Being taken off the court at the end of games in November doesn't mean Hart won't be closing games in April and May.
But his financial future is more uncertain. Towns has a player option for $61M, which would push the Knicks into the second apron next season. Backup Deuce McBride is a free agent. If the team needs to cut payroll, Hart is the most expendable member of the Knicks' championship starting five.
Even if he is best friends with Brunson. It's no wonder Hart's uncertain future is weighing on his performance, but he's got a giant financial incentive to get into a better headspace and turn things around.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!