x
How Fernando Mendoza's debut stacks up to 5 QBs who were also No. 1 picks in NFL Draft
Las Vegas Raiders quarterback Fernando Mendoza. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

How Fernando Mendoza's debut stacks up to 5 QBs who were also No. 1 picks in NFL Draft

Las Vegas Raiders rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza made his NFL debut on Sunday against the Seattle Seahawks. It wasn't the outcome he wanted. 

Mendoza, the No. 1 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, lost to the defending Super Bowl champions 21-13. The Raiders are now 4-6, while the Seahawks are 6-4. 

"The Seahawks have a fantastic defense. We've seen it all season," Mendoza said postgame. "A lot of credit to them. ...It's good to get punched in the face because now it's a great opportunity to grow and learn and to really unveil all the deficiencies that I have in my game and (become) a future hopeful leader of this offense."

Mendoza wanting to improve from Sunday's performance is a positive, but he shouldn't beat himself up over it. Plenty of QBs who also went No. 1 struggled in their debuts. With that in mind, let's see how the former Indiana Hoosier compares to five. Before diving in, please look at his stats below. 

Fernando Mendoza 

Result: 21-13 loss to Seattle Seahawks

Passing stats

Completions/Attempts 
17-of-29
Completion percentage 
58.6 percent
Yards
143
TDs
0
Interceptions 
0
Rushing stats

Carries
6
Yards
22
TDs
1

Caleb Williams (Chicago Bears, 2024)

Result: 24-17 win over Tennessee Titans 

Passing stats

Completions/Attempts 
14-of-29
Completion percentage 
48.3 percent
Yards 
93
TDs
0
Interceptions 
0
Rushing stats

Carries
5
Yards 
15
TDs 
0

In his pro debut, Williams was like the kid who did little work on his group project but still got an A. The Bears forced three turnovers against Tennessee, erasing a 17-3 halftime deficit.

The win over Tennessee foreshadowed the accuracy problems that plagued Williams throughout his rookie season (62.5 completion percentage, No. 31 in NFL). Since Ben Johnson became the Bears head coach in 2025, the former USC Trojan has become a much more precise passer. Entering Monday, he ranked third in the league in completion percentage (68.7 percent), behind San Francisco 49ers QB Brock Purdy (70.1 percent) and Cincinnati Bengals QB Joe Burrow (74.7 percent).

Bryce Young (Carolina Panthers, 2023)

Result: 24-10 loss to the Atlanta Falcons 

Passing stats

Completions/Attempts 
20-of-38
Completion percentage 
52.6 percent
Yards 
146
TDs
1
Interceptions
2
Rushing stats

Carries 
3
Yards 
17
TDs 
0

2021 Heisman winner Young deserves credit for surviving a nightmarish start to his NFL career. The former Alabama Crimson Tide standout went 2-14 as a starter during his rookie season and was benched following Week 2 of the 2024 season. That may have saved his career. 

Young rebounded in 2025, going 8-8 in 16 starts and leading the Panthers to the playoffs. This season, he's 4-5 but ranks eighth in the league in passing yards (2,397) and 12th in TD passes (16). We'll see if Carolina rewards him with a second contract this offseason. 

Trevor Lawrence (Jacksonville Jaguars, 2021) 

Result: 37-21 loss to the Houston Texans 

Passing stats

Completions/Attempts
28-of-51
Completion percentage 
54.9 percent
Yards 
332
TDs
3
Interceptions 
3
Rushing stats

Carries 
1
Yards 
-2
TDs 
0

Lawrence's debut previewed one of his biggest problems early in his career: coaching. Urban Meyer served as Jags HC in his rookie season in one of the worst tenures in league history, going 2-11 before being fired. Doug Pederson replaced him in 2022, but he was only a slight improvement, going 22-29 in three seasons.

Since the Jaguars hired HC Liam Coen in 2025, Lawrence, a Clemson Tigers product, has begun living up to his predraft billing. In 26 games under the HC, the QB has gone 20-6, tossing 50 TDs and 17 interceptions.

Jared Goff (Los Angeles Rams, 2016) 

Result: 14-10 loss to Miami Dolphins 

Passing stats

Completions/Attempts 
17-of-31
Completion percentage 
54.8 percent
Yards 
134
TDs
0
Interceptions 
0
Rushing stats

Carries 
4
Yards 
11
TDs
0

Goff's rookie season would only get worse after his debut, finishing 0-7 as a starter. The former California Golden Bear flourished after the Rams replaced Jeff Fisher with HC Sean McVay before the 2017 season, reaching the Super Bowl during the 2018 season and making two of his five Pro Bowls.

McVay gave up on Goff after the team failed to make it back to the big game in 2019 and 2020, trading him to the Detroit Lions for Matthew Stafford. Goff didn't get a Hollywood ending, but he didn't let that ruin his career. The QB instead made the Motor City home. He has gone 55-35-1 in five seasons with the franchise and led it to the NFC Championship Game. 

Eli Manning (New York Giants, 2004)

Result: 14-10 loss to Atlanta Falcons 

Passing stats

Completions/Attempts 
17-of-37
Completion percentage 
45.9 percent
Yards 
162
TDs 
1
Interceptions 
2
Rushing stats

Carries 
1
Yards 
-1
TDs
0

Manning refusing to play for the San Diego Chargers (now in L.A.), who eventually traded him to the Giants for Philip Rivers, was controversial. So, it's no surprise New York's decision to start him was as well. The Giants handed the former Ole Miss Rebel the keys, despite Kurt Warner leading the team to a respectable 5-4 start. The squad went 1-6 with Manning as the starter. 

New York fans forgave him for that a long time ago. Manning, of course, beat former New England Patriots QB Tom Brady in Super Bowls XLII and XLVI. He's also the franchise's all-time passing leader (4,895-of-8,119 passing for 57,023 yards and 366 TDs).   

Clark Dalton

Clark Dalton is a 2022 journalism graduate of the University of Texas at Austin. He gained experience in sports media over the past seven years — from live broadcasting and creating short films to podcasting and producing. In college, he wrote for The Daily Texan. He loves sports and enjoys hiking, kayaking and camping.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!