
On Monday, MLB announced the 2027 Hall of Fame Ballot. The list includes 13 returning players and an additional 14 first-timers.
That's coming off the 2026 Hall of Fame, which saw Carlos Beltran elected in his fourth year and Andruw Jones make it after nine years on the ballot, along with Jeff Kent from the Contemporary Ballot. None of the 12-timers were elected last year, with 11 not on the ballot this year.
This year, a total of 27 players are on the ballot, and one stands out. That player is Buster Posey . The 12-year veteran played his entire career with the San Francisco Giants from 2009 to 2021.
During his career, Posey was one of the most consistent catchers in the league. His career started with a 2010 Rookie of the Year award when Posey hit .305 with a .862 OPS along with 18 home runs and 67 RBI.
In 2012, Posey won the NL MVP, posting a 7.6 WAR, a .336 average, a .957 OPS, with 24 home runs and 103 RBI. Throughout his career, Posey was a seven-time All-Star and a five-time Silver Slugger winner, along with a batting title (2012) and a Gold Glove (2016).
On top of his individual statistics, Posey won three World Series with the Giants in 2010, 2012 and 2014.
Posey finished his career with a .302 average, a .372 OBP, an .831 OPS and a career 129 OPS+.
There have been 20 catchers elected to the Hall of Fame. Posey's average and OBP would both rank seventh among that group, while his .460 would tie him for ninth with Ernie Lombardi.
Posey's accolades and his career averages should have him lined up for the Hall of Fame, but accolades and averages aren't the whole story.
The reasons against Posey's case start with his longevity. Posey only played in 12 MLB seasons and retired after his age-34 season.
Amongst the 20 catchers in the Hall, their careers lasted an average of 17.2 seasons (Including time played in the Negro Leagues when applicable), well above Posey's 12.
During his career, Posey only finished with 1,500 hits, 158 HRs, 729 RBI and 45 WAR accumulated. Those numbers are well below the average Hall of Fame batter. According to Baseball Reference, the average batter finished their career with 2,331 hits, 228 HRs, 1,207 RBI and a WAR of 67.
Again, within the group of catchers, Posey's career hits rank 13th, home runs 12th, RBI 14th and WAR 12th.
In the group of catchers, Posey ranks fairly in the middle of the pack, but amongst the group of Hall of Fame batters, his numbers are too low.
Posey was one of the best players of the 2010s; there's no question about that. In terms of the best of all time, his longevity and career totals fall short.
That being said, Posey does deserve to be a member of the Hall of Fame one day. His accolades and importance to each of the Giants' three World Series titles are irreplaceable.
Posey, like all other players, has 10 years on the ballot, barring a vote total below 5%, which is extremely unlikely for a player of Posey's caliber.
Despite everything, Posey will most likely not be a first-ballot pick for the Hall, but should find his way over the course of the next 10 years.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!