x
Overrated, underrated or properly rated? Evaluating CFP rankings
Wake Forest Demon Deacons quarterback Gio Lopez. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Overrated, underrated or properly rated? Evaluating all 12 teams in third CFP rankings

The College Football Playoff Selection Committee released its third set of rankings on Tuesday night. They're still sparking intense debate.

Yardbarker will again chime in, offering its own evaluation of the rankings until the 12-team field is finalized on Dec. 6. We'll assess whether the teams in the projected bracket are overrated, underrated or properly rated. 

Please note we're looking at the CFP bracket. Thus, we'll include the highest-ranked remaining conference champion, even if that team is ranked at or near No. 25. 

Before diving in, please take a look at the 12-team bracket. Teams are listed in numerical order.

1. Georgia Bulldogs (9-1, 7-1 SEC) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 1 

Verdict: Properly rated

It's almost getting boring seeing Georgia listed No. 1 at the top of the poll each week, but fans may need to get used to it. Head coach Kirby Smart's squad may be separating itself as the best in the country.

Including the 48-21 blowout of Missouri Tigers at home in Week 11, the Bulldogs have won their last three games by 19 points or more. That has made them the national title favorite in the eyes of oddsmakers. As of Tuesday night, FanDuel Sportsbook gives Georgia +200 odds to hoist the CFP trophy. It will aim to keep gaining momentum in Saturday's road game against the No. 21-ranked South Carolina Gamecocks (ABC, 7:30 p.m. ET).  

2. Utah Utes (10-0, 7-0 Big 12) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 2

Verdict: Properly rated 

Utah escaped by the skin of its teeth in a 40-39 road win over the Arizona Wildcats in Week 11, but that shouldn't count against the Utes. Arizona — which ranks fourth in the Big 12 in strength of record (25), per ESPN's Football Power Index — is no cupcake. SOR measures how a team's win-loss record compares to the best teams in college football. 

Utah still ranks 10th nationally in average margin of victory (+15.7). It could reassert its dominance in a road matchup against the 5-5 TCU Horned Frogs on Saturday (Fox, 9 p.m. ET). 

3. Alabama Crimson Tide (8-2, 6-2 SEC) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 3

Verdict: Overrated 

At this point, it feels like we're picking on Alabama, which we have deemed overrated every week thus far. But you should be skeptical of a team that led the 4-6 Vanderbilt Commodores 7-3 at halftime in Week 11. It won 21-6, but a top-three team in the CFP should win by more. 

The Crimson Tide, though, will likely remain here. They host the Chattanooga Mocs, an FCS program, on Saturday (SEC Network+, 2 p.m. ET).

4. UCLA Bruins (10-0, 7-0 Big Ten) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 4 

Verdict: Overrated 

UCLA is quickly proving it's not a pretender, but it's still slightly overrated because it lacks signature wins. The Bruins only have one ranked win this season (a 17-15 victory over the then-ranked No. 13 Oregon Ducks on Oct. 10). Note: That was an Associated Press poll ranking. 

Unfortunately for the Bruins, they can't earn another in Week 12. UCLA faces the 5-5 Michigan Wolverines on the road before hosting the No. 18-ranked USC Trojans in its regular-season finale. 

5. Texas Longhorns (8-2, 5-2 SEC) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 6

Verdict: Overrated 

Yes, Texas beat the LSU Tigers 22-21 in a thrilling prime-time clash in "Death Valley" in Week 11, but they could've easily lost. That's been the case many times for the Longhorns, who have been raising their fan base's collective blood pressure to alarmingly high levels throughout the season. 

Texas has five ranked wins, but four of those were one-possession victories. The Longhorns better not need more late-game magic at home against the Arkansas Razorbacks (4-6) on Saturday, or the committee may be wondering if placing them this high was a mistake.

6. Notre Dame Fighting Irish (9-1, independent) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 5 

Verdict: Underrated

Notre Dame crushed the Boston College Eagles 41-7 at home in Week 11. And yet, the committee didn't reward the Irish for that dominant win. 

No biggie for the Irish, who could once again flex their muscles in Saturday's home game against the SMU Mustangs (7-3). As of Tuesday night, DraftKings Sportsbook lists Notre Dame as a 20.5-point favorite in the matchup.

7. Miami Hurricanes (9-0, 7-1 ACC) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 7 

Verdict: Underrated 

Miami passed an important test in a 36-25 Week 11 win over the Duke Blue Devils, winning without star wide receiver Malachi Toney. He could miss two more weeks because of an ankle injury.

The committee may be concerned about whether the ACC has provided any true tests for Miami, which hosts another unranked opponent (Virginia Tech Hokies) in Week 12. But as long as quarterback Darian Mensah (29 TD passes, tied for No. 2 in FBS) is balling, the Hurricanes should be a tough out for any team in the field.

8. Indiana Hoosiers (9-1, 6-1 Big Ten) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 9

Verdict: Properly rated

Indiana's offense looked much improved with Grant Wilson starting at QB instead of Josh Hoover in a 27-13 Week 11 win over USC. But the committee should be wanting to see more from the Hoosiers. 

The Trojans rank 15th in the Big Ten in passing yards allowed (229.6 YPG), making them a poor measuring stick for Wilson, who has yet to prove he can lead the team to a second straight national championship. If Wilson backslides in Saturday's road game against the Washington Huskies (217.2 passing yards per game allowed, No. 13 in the Big Ten), that would indicate the QB isn't the answer.

9. Tennessee Volunteers (8-2, 5-2 SEC) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 8

Verdict: Properly rated 

Tennessee's passing attack may ultimately keep it out of the upper echelon of CFP teams. In a 22-7 win over the Texas A&M Aggies in Week 11, QB George MacIntyre threw for just 109 yards. Entering Week 12, the Volunteers rank last in the SEC in passing yardage (171.5 YPG).

However, the Volunteers defense — which ranks eighth nationally in points allowed (14.9 PPG) — is stellar. It may ground LSU and head coach Lane Kiffin in Tennessee's home game on Saturday. 

10. BYU Cougars (8-2, 5-2 Big 12) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 10 

Verdict: Overrated 

It's not that BYU doesn't belong in the final 12. It's just that another team may deserve a top-10 spot (more on that squad later). 

The Cougars, though, remain in contention to win the Big 12 after crushing the Baylor Bears 28-7 in Week 12. They should keep rolling in Saturday's road game against the Kansas Jayhawks. 

11. Wake Forest Demon Deacons (9-1, 6-1 ACC) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 13 

Verdict: Underrated

It's about time Wake Forest is in the 12-team field. One could argue the Demon Deacons could be one spot higher. They rank second nationally in average margin of victory (+23.6). For context, BYU ranks 31st (+7.3). 

Wake Forest HC Jake Dickert made it clear he's never going to take his foot off the gas during a 49-7 win over SMU in Week 11. His squad must keep going full throttle in Saturday's road matchup against the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets to remain in the CFP hunt. 

12. Boise State Broncos (9-1, 6-0 Pac-12) | Last week's projected seeding: No. 12 

Verdict: Properly rated

Boise State would earn the last spot over the No. 12 Texas Tech Red Raiders if the CFP rankings became final Tuesday. The Broncos should keep a firm hold of this spot, barring a hiccup. 

ESPN FPI gives the Broncos a 78 percent chance to win the conference. They could improve those odds with a home win over the San Diego State Aztecs on Saturday. 

Clark Dalton

Clark Dalton is a 2022 journalism graduate of the University of Texas at Austin. He gained experience in sports media over the past seven years — from live broadcasting and creating short films to podcasting and producing. In college, he wrote for The Daily Texan. He loves sports and enjoys hiking, kayaking and camping.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!