x
Trading Maikel Garcia leaves another hole in Royals' porous lineup
Kansas City Royals third baseman Maikel Garcia. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Trading Maikel Garcia leaves another hole in Royals' porous lineup

The Kansas City Royals' lineup was a distinct weakness in 2026. 

Although the Royals lineup as a whole posted a respectable 102 OPS+ (league average is 100), the bulk of the production came from shortstop Bobby Witt Jr., catcher Carter Jensen and right fielder Jac Caglianone. Removing those three left the rest of the Royals lineup at -64.2 OFF (a metric equal to batting runs above average plus base-running runs above average), easily one of the worst in the majors. As it was, the Royals ranked 22nd with 690 runs scored — Witt, Jensen and Caglianone either scored or drove in 388 of those runs.

As the rest of the lineup struggled in general, it would seemingly behoove the Royals to work to improve their offense. Likewise, if third baseman Maikel Garcia could remain healthy and replicate his breakout 2025 performance, the Royals lineup would be more dangerous.

Kansas City Royals made mistake in trading Maikel Garcia

Instead, Garcia is out the door. He, along with reliever James McArthur and minor league reliever L.P. Langevin, was traded to the Seattle Mariners for pitchers Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and Jose Ferrer.

Miller should slot into the middle of the Royals rotation while Ferrer, if right, can help their beleaguered bullpen. Evans provides depth that the Royals sorely needed. 

While that trio does fill a need, it does not address the biggest concern. The Royals still need to score for their improved pitching staff to matter. It is impossible to win a game 0-0, although Witt, Caglianone and Jensen should provide some offense.

As it currently stands, utility man Nick Loftin is slated to get the bulk of the action at third. He was exactly league average in 2026, posting a .240/.322/.388 batting line (100 OPS+) with eight homers and 27 doubles in his 426 plate appearances. That performance was also the best of his career since establishing himself in the majors in 2024. Free agency may not offer many solutions outside of Terauki Sato either, with Alec Bohm and Eugenio Suarez the best of an underwhelming class of available players.

The Royals already had holes in center, left field, second base and the designated hitter roles heading into the offseason. Trading Garcia has added another hole that the Royals will need to fill if they are to realistically harbor hopes of contending for a playoff berth in 2027.

David Hill

Based in the mountains of Vermont, Dave has over a decade of experience writing about all things baseball. Just don't ask his thoughts on the universal DH.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!