x
CFB Week 12 winners, losers: Lane Kiffin's Year 1 LSU flop
LSU Tigers head coach Lane Kiffin. USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

CFB Week 12 winners, losers: Lane Kiffin's Year 1 LSU flop; CFP door opens for Iowa

It was another chaotic week in College Football with two top-10 teams losing to unranked teams, and a couple of first-year coaches not delivering what was hoped for in an effort to turn their new programs around.

Now it is time to take a look at some of the biggest winners and losers from Week 12 of the College Football season. 

Winner: Arch Manning, Texas

Texas and Arch Manning have done a lot of winning this season, but it has not always been a great showing or had a great process behind it. In a 45-3 win over Arkansas on Saturday, they had the results and the process behind to make it all look good. Manning played one of his best, most efficient games of the season, and did what you want to see a top-tier quarterback do against a sub-par opponent — he dominated. 

Loser: Lane Kiffin, LSU

If it wasn't already obvious before, you can officially call the first year of the Kiffin era at LSU a complete flop. 

The Tigers were a 27-13 loser at Tennessee on Saturday, dropping them to 6-5 on the season.

Sam Leavitt was obviously not the right quarterback, and there were some bad breaks at times this season, but given the hype that existed at the start, this was by no means the expectation. 

The pressure is going to be on to fix this next season, and fix it rapidly. He was not hired to take his time. He was hired to win, and win immediately. So far, he is not. 

Winner: Iowa Hawkeyes and Big Ten conference chaos

The College Football Playoff committee might not love them, but thanks to their win over Illinois on Saturday, as well as losses by Indiana and UCLA, the door is open for them to sneak their way into the Big Ten championship game, and perhaps the College Football Playoff. 

A few things need to go right next week for that to happen (read about them here), but it is not a far-fetched possibility. The Hawkeyes have a chance. Do not sleep on them. 

Loser: Penn State

Penn State lost to Rutgers on a walk-off two-point conversion, following a last-second touchdown on a desperation lateral as time expired in the fourth quarter. 

That is bad enough. 

But it gets even worse when you peel back the layers. 

The Nittany Lions were a 24.5-point favorite, making their loss the second-largest upset of the season. 

That is a bad look for first-year coach Matt Campbell, who seems to be in over his head so far in the Big Ten. But it is also not entirely a Campbell problem, as this was the third time Penn State has lost as a 20-point favorite over the past two years.

The remaining FBS teams have just six such losses... combined. 

Winner: Mark Fletcher, Miami

The Hurricanes clinched a spot in the ACC Championship game by overcoming a 14-point deficit against the Virginia Tech Hokies, and did so without wide receiver Malachi Toney. The star of the win was Fletcher, who rushed for three touchdowns, giving him 39 for his career at the school. 

Loser: Ohio State's playoff chances

Before this season, Ohio State had not lost four games in a season since that forgettable Luke Fickell campaign in 2011. 

The Buckeyes now have four losses thanks to a 31-28 defeat at Nebraska, which all but ended whatever College Football Playoff hopes they might have had entering the week. 

If they do not beat Michigan next week, things are going to get ugly for head coach Ryan Day. 

Winner: Houston running back Makhi Hughes

The No. 20 Cougars went on the road to West Virginia and came away with a 34-31 win, with Hughes completely taking over the game.

He not only scored three touchdowns, but he also rushed for 158 yards on 19 carries (8.3 yards per carry) as they overcame a 10-point second-half deficit. 

He helped take a lot of the pressure off freshman quarterback Keisean Henderson, who was making his first career start (and played extremely well, completing 18-of-28 passes for 268 yards and a touchdown). 

Loser: Colorado State's defense

This unit has allowed at least 30 points in nine straight games, including eight games allowing more than 40 points. Over the past three games alone, they have allowed 186 points. That is 62 points per game. 

Loser: James Franklin vs. The top-10

Nobody was expecting Franklin's Virginia Tech team to go into Miami and win, and they did put up a valiant effort. But the harsh reality is that it is another loss for Franklin against a top-10 team, dropping him to 1-23 all-time against top-10 opponents. That is the worst record for a coach in the AP Poll era. 

Adam Gretz

Adam Gretz is a freelance writer based in Pittsburgh. He covers the NHL, NFL, MLB and NBA. Baseball is his favorite sport -- he is nearly halfway through his goal of seeing a game in every MLB ballpark. Catch him on X @AGretz

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!