Manchester United will look to the January transfer window to strengthen their team even more, but it will depend on Rúben Amorim’s future
Manchester United have stumbled into the new campaign under Rúben Amorim with far too many questions and very few convincing answers. They sit 11th in the Premier League as of 25 September 2025, their worst opening since 1992/93. The defeat to Arsenal and the heavy loss to Manchester City highlight how far the side still must go, while even a win against Chelsea failed to hide the inconsistency across the pitch.
Injuries to Lisandro Martínez, Matheus Cunha and Mason Mount have reduced the options on the bench to some extent. Their elimination from the EFL Cup by Grimsby Town on penalties rubbed salt into fresh wounds. With the team already under pressure, reports suggest that Marco Silva now stands among the possible candidates if Amorim loses his job. This underlines how fragile his position feels even at this early stage.
According to Football Insider, football finance expert Dan Plumley has warned that United may react by spending heavily in January if the league position does not improve. His comments reflect the mood of many supporters who fear the season may drift into familiar frustration. He suggested that the club might make a big statement in the market if results fail to improve, while a fallback option could see renewed efforts for Brighton midfielder Carlos Baleba.
That prospect feels both exciting and worrying, because while United certainly have financial muscle, fans do not want the club to rely on sudden transfer splurges again. Plumley stressed the lack of patience, both in the fanbase and the boardroom, as the club cannot keep reliving the same cycle of poor starts followed by mid-season decisions. Reports in Spain indicate that Manchester United are unlikely to land Real Madrid midfielder Federico Valverde. That news removes one attractive option and complicates matters further.
“In terms of splashing big cash in January, I think that’s going to be dependent on where they are in the league, and if they have to make a big statement because things aren’t going well.
“They can probably go and do that, but if they don’t, they might go back to Baleba and try and do that deal in January.
“I think after last season, I just wonder how much patience there is across the board from fans, the hierarchy, whoever that may be at that club.
“I guess there’s a question about how much patience they have to have another season like last season?
“Manchester United can’t keep doing that. That’s not gonna work.”
Looking ahead, Amorim’s immediate future will shape the entire direction of the January window. If he remains, strengthening the midfield looks certain to top the list, with United likely to view Baleba as a key target. At the same time, a cheaper option such as Rúben Neves, available for around €20 million from Saudi Arabia, makes sense, especially as he fits Amorim’s tactical ideas and brings proven Premier League quality. The Manchester Evening News continues to mention other names like Elliot Anderson and Adam Wharton, yet their inclusion only highlights how many possible routes United could take.
Should Amorim depart, a new manager would almost certainly bring his own demands, which risks delaying much-needed reinforcements, but even then United as a club cannot ignore the midfield woes. Beyond that, a centre-back such as Jarrad Branthwaite from Everton would provide crucial cover, especially with Martínez’s injury record becoming more concerning. Fans want action, yet they also want clarity and a genuine long-term plan rather than short bursts of reaction. Until that arrives, the suspicion lingers that United will keep repeating mistakes while the league table refuses to forgive.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!