The referee at the centre of the Julian Alvarez ‘double touch’ penalty has finally spoken out over his decision.
The story has dominated headlines across Europe following Atletico Madrid’s dramatic UEFA Champions League penalty shootout defeat to Real Madrid on March 13.
Los Rojiblancos tied the game at 2-2 on aggregate as Conor Gallagher’s early goal brought the contest level in the last 16 second leg.
However, controversy reigned at the Estadio Metropolitano as Alvarez’s spot kick was controversially ruled out Polish official Szymon Marciniak and his team.
After a brief consultation with his VAR, Marciniak ruled out Alvarez’s effort – which had beat Thibaut Courtois – as Atletico Madrid’s second penalty of the shootout.
The Argentinian was adjudged to have touched the ball twice as he slipped over when converting but any ‘second contact’ remains widely debated.
From expert video analysis/slow motion replays, amid claims of it never happening before – and Atletico Madrid being unfairly punished – the football world have been enthralled by the row.
However, the person with the most questions to answer is Marciniak, and he is clear in his view of the call being correct despite breaking new ground for everyone involved.
“I was the one who informed the VAR there was a 99% chance Alvarez touched the ball twice, and they checked it thoroughly,” he said.
“It’s absolutely false that Mbappe said anything to me about two touches.
“Honestly, I had never faced such a situation in my refereeing career, but the players are aware of the rules.”
The row is expected to roll on until the end of the campaign with Diego Simeone claiming post match that no one could be clear over the matter.
The two rivals can still potentially face each other before the 2024/25 campaign end if they reach the Copa del Rey final in April.
More must-reads:
Didi Hamann has said that the Liverpool hierarchy will be ‘laughing’ over one particular piece of business they completed this summer. Two weeks ago, the Reds completed the sale of Luis Diaz to Bayern Munich for a reported £65.5m (The Guardian), turning a profit on a player who cost an initial £37.5m to sign from FC Porto in January 2022 (£50m including add-ons). Further reports indicated that, due to the inclusion of realistically achievable add-ons and a sell-on clause for a future transfer, the Merseyside giants could yet earn the best part of £90m from selling the Colombian, who’ll turn 29 in January. Hamann: Liverpool will be ‘laughing’ after £65m Diaz sale to Bayern In an interview with Austrian outlet Heute, Hamann took aim at the Bundesliga champions over how much they paid for the forward, not just in terms of the transfer fee but also his wages. The former Liverpool midfielder (who also played for Bayern) said: “Diaz is a very good footballer, but what Bayern are doing isn’t a business model. Bringing in a 28-year-old for that amount of money and then paying him even more than he earned in England? Liverpool are laughing.” Let’s hope Liverpool won’t regret selling Diaz this summer… Having already had their attacking options lessened by the tragic death of Diogo Jota at the start of July, it may have seemed surprising that the Reds would sanction the exit of Diaz, who was our third-highest scorer last season with 17 goals. However, with LFC having the opportunity to make a profit on a player whose resale value will almost certainly diminish from hereon, and for whom negotiations over a new contract hadn’t been going smoothly, the Anfield hierarchy may ultimately feel justified in cashing in on him this summer. Liverpool fans will hope that Arne Slot hasn’t been left short in attack for the new campaign, particularly after Darwin Nunez’s move to Al-Hilal in recent days, but the ongoing pursuit of Alexander Isak suggests that efforts are being made to redress that imbalance. By leaving off the back of a glorious season at a personal and collective level with a Premier League winners medal in his back pocket, Diaz has at least ensured that he departed with his reputation among Kopites firmly intact, and he’ll be warmly welcomed back on any future visits to L4. Hamann most certainly feels that FSG made the right decision to part with the Colombian this summer – let’s hope the Reds don’t have cause to regret it over the coming months and years!
Jon Gruden sent another warning shot toward the NFL after scoring a major win in court. On Tuesday, Gruden welcomed a ruling that will force the NFL to litigate the circumstances of his firing in court rather than closed-door arbitration. The former Las Vegas Raiders coach made it clear that he intends to continue his legal challenge to the NFL, ensuring that they are held accountable. “I’m looking forward to having the truth come out, and I want to make sure what happened to me doesn’t happen to anyone else,” Gruden said in a statement provided to ESPN’s Don Van Natta Jr. “The league’s actions disrupted the whole season. We were leading the division at the time and they completely blindsided me and the team.” The Raiders were 3-1 in 2021 when Gruden was forced to resign after offensive emails he had sent between 2011 and 2018 were leaked. Gruden has alleged that the NFL leaked the emails to force him out of a job after obtaining them during an investigation into the Washington Commanders. The NFL is set to appeal Monday’s ruling, but if that appeal fails, the league may be forced into public discovery. One alternative would be to offer Gruden a settlement, but he has not said whether or not he would be interested in such a resolution. Gruden has not held an NFL coaching job since the Raiders forced him out. He has recently spoken about possibly making a return to coaching at the college level.
New York Jets quarterback Justin Fields found out he has a long way to go following his performance at Tuesday's joint practice with the New York Giants. Per Connor Hughes of SNY TV, Fields started hot at the practice before struggling during the move-the-ball period. "Very interesting practice for #Jets QB Justin Fields," Hughes posted on X. "He finished 7 of 12 with a TD. 5 of 5 to start practice. Then 0 for 4. Finished 2 of 3 with the really impressive TD to Jeremy Ruckert in red zone (starter 18 yard line). "The offensive performance was a bit alarming in move-the-ball period of practice. Fields Co. had three attempts to get down field. They didn’t gain a first down. Only gained yards twice (two short Breece Hall runs). Three sacks. That needs to be fixed. #Giants defense toyed with NYJ during that period." Some Jets fans online thought Hughes was using hyperbole to characterize the practice, but he doubled down on his judgment of the offense. Fields looked strong on his first and only drive in the Jets' 30-10 win over the Green Bay Packers on Saturday night. He went 3-of-4 passing for 42 yards and rushed two times for 14 yards and a touchdown. However, the Giants defense at the joint practice is a much better unit than the short-handed one the Packers trotted out for the first preseason game. Fields' issues seen with the Chicago Bears and Pittsburgh Steelers, with holding the ball too long and not being able to pass consistently downfield, were a factor against the Giants. Following Saturday's game, Jets head coach Aaron Glenn said Fields was getting better but had a lot to improve on. Tuesday's practice was a humbling reminder that Fields needs to become a consistent passer if the Jets are going to move the ball on good defenses in the regular season.
The MLB regular season is roughly 75 percent complete. Plenty has changed since the start of the season, but one constant is New York Yankees superstar outfielder Aaron Judge. On Tuesday, ESPN updated its top-50 player rankings. Judge, who was fourth on the World Wide Leader's initial 2025 rankings of baseball's best players in early April, claimed the top spot. Los Angeles Dodgers DH/starting pitcher Shohei Ohtani, Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. and Dodgers shortstop Mookie Betts rounded out the top four on the April list. Just over four months later, Judge edged Ohtani for No. 1. ESPN shared the article with the fully updated rankings on X (formerly Twitter). Judge is raking again this season, posting 37 HRs and 87 RBI with an impressive .336 BA through 109 games. It's fair to wonder where the spiraling New York Yankees (63-56 through Monday) would be without his production. Ohtani, meanwhile, hasn't done anything to drop down in the rankings; it's just hard to argue with the numbers Judge is putting up. The 31-year-old Dodgers star has 42 HRs and 78 RBI and a .284 batting average in 117 games. Plus, he has a 2.37 ERA and 25 strikeouts in 19 innings. Among the biggest risers on ESPN's list are Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (86th in April to fourth) and Cubs outfielder Pete Crow-Armstrong (unranked to seventh). For Betts and Astros outfielder Yordan Alvarez, 2025 hasn't been as kind. Both fell from the top 10 to outside the top 50 altogether. The most important games of the season are still to come, and that's where Judge and Ohtani could add a few more bullet points to their already impressive resumes.
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!