Tottenham Hotspur secured a 3-1 win over Southampton in a somewhat low-tempo affair on Sunday afternoon, but the match still delivered its share of late drama. In stoppage time, Spurs were awarded a penalty, which was calmly converted by substitute Mathys Tel to round off the scoreline. However, the decision surrounding the penalty taker has sparked controversy.
Brennan Johnson, who had already netted twice and won the spot-kick, was denied the chance to complete his hat-trick. Instead, Cristian Romero insisted that Mathys Tel take the penalty, believing the young forward needed the goal more for confidence. As expected, the move has triggered widespread debate among fans and pundits alike.
Brennan Johnson began the season brightly, finding the net regularly and showing glimpses of his attacking potential. However, as the campaign progressed, his form dipped, eventually seeing him reduced to more of an impact substitute role in the second half of games.
The Welsh international also faced a wave of criticism and social media abuse, which ultimately led him to delete his online accounts. But to his credit, Johnson has responded in the best way possible, on the pitch. His recent resurgence in form has reignited his confidence and brought back the self-belief and swagger that every top forward needs.
Following the win over Southampton, Brennan Johnson addressed the penalty incident, offering a calm and mature perspective. He admitted that it felt natural for him to take the spot-kick, especially after scoring twice and winning the penalty. However, with the game effectively sealed, Johnson explained that he didn’t want to create unnecessary tension or cause a scene. Instead, he chose to accept the decision and move on without making it an issue, a response that reflects both his professionalism and growing maturity.
The Winger speaking to media after the Southampton game, showed his professionalism and maturity
“It’s only normal for me to want to take the penalty. There’s only a certain amount of talking to do before it gets quite messy. I’ve been in the situation before when I’ve had people wanting to take the ball off me and it kind of unsettles you a little bit. I knew the game was pretty much done but still, I didn’t want to unsettle anyone or start any disagreements. So, once the decision was made, I just had to get on with it.”
️| Brennan Johnson on not taking the penalty which could’ve seen him complete a hattrick:
— The Spurs Express (@TheSpursExpress) April 6, 2025
“It's only normal for me to want to take the penalty. There's only a certain amount of talking to do before it gets quite messy. I've been in the situation before when I've had people… pic.twitter.com/kl6JpeD64f
Brennan Johnson made history with his brace against Southampton, becoming the first Welsh player to hit double digits in a Premier League season since Gareth Bale’s 2020/21 campaign with Spurs. While aspects of his overall play still draw criticism from sections of the fanbase, his goal tally speaks volumes.
Many of his strikes may have come against lower-ranked opposition, but that’s true for plenty of players across the league. What stands out is that Johnson is the only Tottenham player to reach the ten-goal mark this season, a clear testament to his efficiency and impact in the final third.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!