New Games Coming to and Leaving Xbox Game Pass: September’s Lineup Looks… Interesting

The Heavy Hitters: What’s Actually Worth Playing

Look, I’m not going to sugarcoat this – September’s lineup isn’t exactly setting the gaming world on fire, but there are a few gems hiding in the rough. Hollow Knight: Silksong finally graces us with its presence on September 4th, and honestly, it’s about damn time. After what feels like a geological age of waiting, Team Cherry is delivering what might be the only reason to boot up your console this month.

Then we’ve got Frostpunk 2 dropping on September 18th, because apparently, we all needed more existential dread in our lives. The first game was a masterclass in making you question your moral compass while managing a frozen wasteland, so naturally, the sequel promises to crush your soul even more efficiently. Can’t wait to disappoint virtual citizens all over again.

Deep Rock Galactic: Survivor rounds out the actually interesting additions on September 17th. Because nothing says “innovation” like taking a beloved co-op mining game and turning it into a survival experience. Though to be fair, the original was pretty fantastic, so maybe this won’t be a complete disaster.

EA’s “Generous” Offerings and Sports Game Shenanigans

Oh, and EA Play subscribers get their usual “treat” – NHL 26 gets a whopping 10-hour trial on September 5th, followed by EA Sports FC 26 on September 19th. Because nothing screams “value” like getting to sample a sports game for less time than it takes to binge-watch a Netflix series.

Seriously, EA, ten hours? That’s barely enough time to figure out the new control scheme, let alone decide if the game is worth the full price tag. But hey, at least they’re consistent in their stinginess.

The Departure Blues: Games Leaving Xbox Game Pass

Now, here’s where things get a bit murky. Microsoft is being mysteriously tight-lipped about what’s leaving Xbox Game Pass this month. They’ve mentioned two batches of departures – one supposedly imminent and another around mid-September – but haven’t bothered to tell us which games are getting the boot.

This radio silence is particularly frustrating because, let’s be honest, the games leaving are often more interesting than what’s coming in. There’s something uniquely painful about discovering a hidden gem on Game Pass only to have it yanked away before you can properly appreciate it. It’s like finding a twenty-dollar bill in your old jeans, except Microsoft comes along and sets your pants on fire.

The Reality Check: What This Means for Subscribers

Let’s talk turkey here. September 2025’s Game Pass lineup feels like Microsoft is coasting. Sure, Silksong is a big deal, and Frostpunk 2 will probably steal hours of your life, but beyond that? We’re looking at a pretty thin month.

This is becoming a concerning pattern. Remember when Game Pass felt like this incredible value proposition where you’d discover amazing games you never would have bought otherwise? Lately, it feels more like a subscription service trying to justify its existence with a handful of decent releases sprinkled between months of mediocrity.

The Waiting Game: More Announcements Coming

To Microsoft’s credit, they’ve admitted this is just the beginning of September’s announcements. Apparently, we can expect more reveals throughout the month, which means either they’re building suspense or they’re scrambling to fill out the roster. Given recent trends, I’m leaning toward the latter.

The promise of additional announcements does offer some hope. Maybe we’ll get a few surprise indie darlings or a forgotten AAA title that suddenly becomes available. But honestly, at this point, I’m not holding my breath for any earth-shattering revelations.

Bottom Line: Managing Expectations

Here’s the thing about new games coming to and leaving Xbox Game Pass – it’s become a game of managing expectations. September 2025 isn’t going to be the month that redefines your gaming library, but it might offer a few pleasant surprises if you know where to look.

Silksong alone makes the month worthwhile for Metroidvania fans, and Frostpunk 2 will satisfy those who enjoy their strategy games with a side of emotional trauma. Everything else? Well, that’s what backlogs are for, right?

The real question isn’t whether September’s lineup is good or bad – it’s whether Microsoft can stop treating Game Pass like a dumping ground for whatever titles they happen to have lying around. Until then, we’ll keep playing this monthly guessing game, hoping next month brings something that doesn’t make us question our subscription choices.

At least we’ll always have our ever-growing pile of unfinished games to keep us company. Thanks, Game Pass. Really. Your commitment to enabling our gaming ADD is truly admirable.

Visit Total Apex Gaming for more game-related news.

Visit Total Apex Gaming for more Xbox-related news.