
Sophie Cunningham's first season with the Indiana Fever was one to remember, but their injured team could not make it past the eventual Finals champion Las Vegas Aces in the semifinals of the WNBA playoffs.
Cunningham averaged 8.6 points, 3.5 rebounds and 1.2 assists in 25.2 minutes per game. She was one of five players, including star point guard Caitlin Clark, who suffered season-ending injuries before the Fever put together their unlikely playoff run that ended just short of the WNBA Finals.
Cunningham promised revenge next season after the team's playoff loss, but the unrestricted free agent has followed with mixed signals this offseason about her future in Indiana.
In an interview with Annie Costabile of Front Office Sports, Cunningham admitted why the Fever may never get a chance to see what their current roster could do if fully healthy.
"If people want to come back, we’re trying to keep our core together," Cunningham said. "But, you know, when money is waved in people’s faces, you just never know."
Much of the uncertainty is tied to ongoing negotiations between the WNBA and its players over a new collective bargaining agreement. The majority of the league, including Cunningham and other key Fever players, is entering free agency anticipating higher salaries in a new CBA.
A Fever fan shouted at Cunningham and Hull that they both need to re-sign.
— Scott Agness (@ScottAgness) November 12, 2025
Cunningham: “Tell them to pay us,” she said, referencing the WNBA and their ongoing CBA negotiations. pic.twitter.com/cX5xmGtatG
For example, Cunningham played on a one-year, $100,000 contract with the Fever in 2025 — tied for third-largest deal per year on the team. One reported proposal would increase the supermax salary from $249,244 to $850,000 in the new CBA, meaning she could reasonably triple or quadruple her salary next season. The question that remains is which team will offer her the sweetest deal.
In her exit interview with the Fever in October, Cunningham said she "can’t just not look at other opportunities" when free agency arrives.
"If people are going to be paying you multi-million dollar deals, why would you not?" Cunningham told Costabile of players joining rival leagues this offseason, offering another lens into her thinking.
Whatever the salary cap ends up being in a potential new CBA, Indiana will have to decide where to prioritize its money between Cunningham and other free agents. Max player Kelsey Mitchell and key contributors Natasha Howard, Lexie Hull, Damiris Dantas and Aari McDonald are all out of contract. On the bright side, All-Stars Clark and Aliyah Boston are still on relatively cheap rookie deals, offering some crucial flexibility.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!