Who Could be the Next Head Coach of the New York Liberty?

Another strong candidate is Kristi Toliver, a two-time WNBA champion and one of the league’s most respected floor generals. She has already logged valuable coaching time in the NBA, working with the Washington Wizards and Dallas Mavericks. Now that her focus has shifted entirely to coaching, Toliver’s reputation for sharp tactical thinking makes her a natural fit. Importantly, players trust her judgment. That trust could prove crucial in New York’s star-driven environment.

Rebekkah Brunson

Equally compelling is Rebekkah Brunson. She is the WNBA’s all-time leading offensive rebounder, and she still holds that record and is a five-time champion with the Minnesota Lynx. Since retirement, she has developed her coaching career as an assistant under Cheryl Reeve in Minnesota. Known for her toughness and relentless work ethic, Brunson understands what it takes to win repeatedly. Her transition from player to coach has been seamless, and she is often described as “head coach material.”

Lisa Leslie

It is impossible to discuss women’s basketball without mentioning Lisa Leslie. A two-time WNBA champion, three-time MVP, and one of the most recognizable names in the sport, she would instantly command attention and respect. Nevertheless, her professional coaching experience is limited. Therefore, hiring Leslie would be as much about culture and branding as it would be about Xs and Os. Still, her presence on the Liberty sidelines would be a historic moment for the league.

Plenette Pierson

Next, Plenette Pierson offers a blend of grit and pedigree. A three-time champion, she was celebrated during her career for her physicality and leadership. Though her coaching résumé is not as long as some of her peers, she has gained experience in player development roles. She could be a surprise choice, one that prioritizes locker-room culture and toughness over traditional coaching credentials.

Lindsey Harding

Currently an assistant coach for the Los Angeles Lakers, Lindsey Harding has carved out an impressive post-playing career. She has worked across the NBA and international circuits, building a reputation as a sharp, detail-oriented basketball mind. Her NBA exposure could give her an edge in advanced scouting and tactical preparation. Harding represents a modern, forward-looking choice — one that could align with New York’s desire for long-term innovation.

Lindsay Whalen

Few names carry the leadership weight of Lindsay Whalen. A four-time WNBA champion and former Minnesota Lynx star, Whalen also served as the head coach at the University of Minnesota. Although her professional coaching experience is less extensive than others, her ability to inspire and connect is undeniable. If the Liberty values intangibles and cultural leadership, Whalen could be an intriguing candidate. Whalen is serving as an assistant coach for the Minnesota Lynx, who lost Game 4 of the semifinals against the Phoenix Mercury.

Crystal Robinson

Crystal Robinson is a Liberty legend whose name remains a lasting legacy among fans. After her playing days, she moved into coaching at both the WNBA and NCAA levels. A return to New York as head coach would carry symbolic power, linking the team’s past to its championship present. Moreover, Robinson’s strong relationships with players would be an asset in navigating a demanding roster.

Teresa Weatherspoon

Another Liberty icon, Teresa Weatherspoon, is one of the most beloved figures in franchise history. Recently, she served as an assistant coach for the New Orleans Pelicans in the NBA and a head coach for the Chicago Sky in the 2024 WNBA season. Known for her charisma and motivational skills, she has the rare ability to inspire loyalty and belief. If the Liberty is looking to reconnect with its roots while also bringing in a leader with professional coaching chops, Weatherspoon could be the answer.

Katie Smith

Katie Smith is another familiar face. A Hall of Famer and one of the most decorated players ever, she previously served as the Liberty’s head coach from 2018 to 2019. Although her tenure produced mixed results, she remains highly respected and served as an assistant with the Minnesota Lynx from 2020 to 2024. Returning Smith would offer continuity, along with the chance to rewrite her Liberty coaching chapter.

Unrealistic but Achievable Dream Hires

Seimone Augustus

Although less likely, Seimone Augustus remains an exciting name in coaching conversations. A four-time WNBA champion and eight-time All-Star, she is now serving as an assistant coach at LSU. Her charisma, offensive creativity, and championship mindset make her a natural leader. It may be too soon for her to take on a high-pressure job like New York, but her presence in the conversation is proof of her bright future.

Candace Parker

Then there is Candace Parker. Recently retired, Parker is one of the greatest players in basketball history. A two-time MVP and three-time WNBA champion, she has long been praised for her high basketball IQ. Although she has not announced coaching ambitions, her leadership qualities would make her a highly sought-after hire. Realistically, the timing may not be reality, but the thought of Parker leading a team in New York is tantalizing.

What the Liberty Needs Most

Transitioning from Brondello, the Liberty must identify a coach who can both preserve their championship identity and push them further. Importantly, the next coach must manage egos, sustain defensive discipline, and foster growth among role players. The WNBA has grown increasingly competitive each year, and New York cannot afford to be complacent. Moreover, whoever steps in must handle the relentless spotlight of New York City, where success is celebrated but failure is magnified.

Final Thoughts

The Liberty are not just hiring a coach — they are choosing the architect of their future. Among realistic candidates, January, Toliver, and Brunson appear to have the strongest cases. January brings defensive toughness, Toliver offers tactical creativity, and Brunson provides championship-tested leadership.

At the same time, legacy names like Weatherspoon and Robinson underscore the franchise’s deep roots. Meanwhile, dream hires like Augustus and Parker remind fans of the star power that continues to circle women’s basketball.

In the end, the Liberty’s decision will not just impact their next season — it will shape the course of the WNBA’s next great dynasty.

Also, follow Beyond Women’s Sports for more from the world of sports.