Sting Returns to AEW at WrestleDream: The Icon Saves Darby Allin One More Time

Look, we all know retirement in wrestling is about as permanent as a New Year’s resolution, but when Sting—yes, that Sting—showed up at AEW WrestleDream 2025, it actually meant something. The 66-year-old legend wasn’t there to relive his glory days or cash a quick paycheck. He was there to do what he’s always done best: save Darby Allin from imminent doom.

The Setup: Violence, Waterboarding, and Death Riders

The “I Quit” match between Darby Allin and Jon Moxley wasn’t your typical main event. These two have been at each other’s throats for weeks—stalking each other at conventions, attempting arson (casual weekend activities, apparently), and brawling in holding cells. So naturally, the pay-per-view needed to deliver something equally unhinged.

And boy, did it deliver.

Moxley, flanked by his Death Riders crew, put Allin through absolute hell. We’re talking wooden sticks shoved under fingernails (ouch), Claudio Castagnoli launching Darby through the announce table like a human javelin, and the liberal use of lighter fluid and tasers. You know, standard wrestling fare.

But here’s the kicker: Allin wouldn’t quit. Not for the pain, not for the chaos, not even when Moxley’s goons dragged out an aquarium filled with water. Yeah, you read that right—waterboarding was apparently on the menu. Mox was fully prepared to drown Darby into submission, because why not add “war crime” to the list of things that happened at WrestleDream?

Enter The Icon

Just when it looked like Allin was about to meet his watery demise, the lights went out. And when they came back on? There he was—Sting, baseball bat in hand, face paint on point, ready to ruin Moxley’s night.

The crowd lost it. I mean, how could they not? Sting choked out Moxley with his signature bat, cleared the ring of Death Riders like they were annoying mosquitoes, and even carried Marina Shafir out over his shoulder. At 66 years old, the man looked like he could still go another decade if he wanted to (please don’t, though—your body has been through enough, sir).

And then, in true mentor fashion, Sting tossed his bat to Darby and walked off into the night, leaving his protégé to finish the job.

Darby’s Revenge: A Scorpion Deathlock for the Ages

With Moxley vulnerable and the Death Riders scattered, Allin went full nostalgia mode. He grabbed the AEW flag he’d carried to the top of Mount Everest (because of course he did) and used it to deliver a Scorpion Death Drop. Then came the Coffin Drop. And finally, the pièce de résistance: a Scorpion Deathlock—Sting’s move—with the flag wrapped around Moxley’s throat for good measure.

Moxley had no choice but to quit. And just like that, WrestleDream ended with Darby Allin standing tall, Sting’s legacy alive and well, and Jon Moxley eating humble pie.

Why This Matters

Sting’s appearance wasn’t just a cheap pop (though it absolutely was that, too). It was a reminder of why storytelling in wrestling still works when it’s done right. Sting has been Allin’s mentor since joining AEW in 2020, and their partnership culminated in a retirement match at AEW Revolution 2024, where they won the AEW World Tag Team Championship together.

Since then, Sting has only appeared sparingly—once at All In London to save Darby from The Young Bucks and Jack Perry, and now at WrestleDream. Each time, it’s been to protect his protégé, to give Darby the edge he needs to overcome impossible odds. It’s poetic, really. And for a guy who’s been wrestling since the ’80s, Sting still knows how to make an entrance count.

The Legacy Continues

Sting made his AEW debut in late 2020, nearly five years after being inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame. His run in AEW has been nothing short of spectacular, proving that age is just a number when you’ve got the charisma and ring presence of a living legend. And while his in-ring career officially ended at Revolution 2024, these surprise appearances show that Sting isn’t quite ready to disappear into the sunset just yet.

As for what’s next? Who knows. Maybe this was truly his last appearance in costume. Maybe he’ll pop up again when Darby needs him most (probably at a very inconvenient time for whoever’s trying to murder him). Either way, Sting’s latest cameo at WrestleDream was a masterclass in how to use a legend without overexposing them.

And honestly? We wouldn’t have it any other way.