Penn State Lacks Fire as Franklin Faces Tough Questions

Penn State football is at a breaking point. A team once viewed as a Big Ten and National title contender now looks uncertain about its identity, its leadership, and its trajectory.

A Program at a Crossroads

Penn State’s 42-37 loss to a winless UCLA team was more than an upset. It was a moment that forced a harder question. What is the true direction of James Franklin’s program? For years, the Nittany Lions have hovered on the edge of contention but failed to break through. Now, with recruiting momentum slowing annually and culture concerns mounting, the margin for error is disappearing.

A Habit of Playing Down to Opponents

Franklin admitted his team came out without the right energy in Pasadena. “We did not come out with the right energy to start the game, and before you know it, obviously, they get a touchdown drive and an onside kick, and now you’re fighting,” he said. “That’s my responsibility, and I didn’t get it done.”

The problem is that this was not an isolated lapse. Penn State has shown the same tendencies all season, even in wins. Against Nevada, FIU, and Villanova, the final scores masked how uncomfortable those games actually felt. At no point did Penn State pass the eye test as a team built to compete with the best in the country. Too often, the Nittany Lions have played down to the level of their opponents, waiting until pressure mounts before showing urgency. That approach has cost them in marquee games, and now against teams they were expected to control.

Missing Leaders Who Change Games

The Nittany Lions have talent, but talent alone has not created the edge that programs like Ohio State, Oregon, Georgia, and even Indiana show every Saturday under fiery head coaches. Penn State lacks players who consistently tilt the field with energy and presence. Dani Dennis-Sutton delivered a blocked punt against UCLA, and Zakee Wheatley once again produced steady tackling numbers, but examples of players who command games from the opening snap are too few.

Quarterback Drew Allar brings calm, steady leadership. His media answers often sound polished, reflecting the preparation he has been trained to show. That composure is valuable, but it does not substitute for urgency. “There’s no other group that I’d rather be in this situation with,” he said. “I know for me personally, I’m going to take it day-by-day and put 100% of my effort into doing whatever I need to do to get us right.” Confidence matters, but without players who take control in critical moments, Penn State continues to fall short.  That mental makeup and toughness (or lack thereof) is directly correlated to the leadership at the top.

Recruiting and Reputation Slipping

Franklin built his early success on the ability to sell a vision of Penn State as a championship-caliber program. But vision has to be backed up by wins. Losses in marquee games have slowed momentum, and now losses to unranked opponents compound the issue. Rivals like Ohio State and Michigan continue to recruit at an elite level. Penn State cannot afford to trail further behind, especially with programs such as Oregon, USC, and Washington now tied to the Big Ten picture.

Franklin addressed the growing noise around the program. “We’ve got to tune out all the outside noise,” he said. “I thought our guys worked hard at doing that last week, but obviously not well enough. There’s going to be a lot out there to divide, divide, divide, and we’ve got to tune all that out and stick together.” Blocking out the noise may insulate the locker room. What is harder to correct is the perception that Penn State is drifting instead of surging.

Recruiting and Reputation Slipping

Franklin built his early success on the ability to sell a vision of Penn State as a championship-caliber program. But vision has to be backed up by wins. Losses in marquee games have slowed momentum, and now losses to unranked opponents compound the issue. Rivals like Ohio State continue to recruit at an elite level. Penn State cannot afford to trail further behind, especially with programs such as Oregon and Washington now entering the Big Ten picture.

Franklin addressed the growing noise around the program. “We’ve got to tune out all the outside noise,” he said. “I thought our guys worked hard at doing that last week, but obviously not well enough. There’s going to be a lot out there to divide, divide, divide, and we’ve got to tune all that out and stick together.” Blocking out the noise may insulate the locker room. What is harder to correct is the perception that Penn State is drifting instead of surging.

A Program at Risk of Slipping

The UCLA loss was more than a setback in the standings. It fed a narrative that Penn State is stuck between tiers. Talented but not feared. Consistent but non-threatening to the elite. Franklin has always sold vision, but vision only lasts if it is backed by defining wins. Without urgency, leadership, and cultural edge, Penn State risks losing not just games but its place among college football’s true contenders. And if that slide continues, the questions about Franklin’s long-term future in State College will only get louder.