Friday night, college football fans were shocked as FCS underdog Tarleton State Texans pulled off a stunning upset over the Army Black Knights in double overtime at Michie Stadium. Social media erupted with reactions, as Army, a 14.5-point favorite and riding a nine-game home winning streak, fell to the Texans, who were paid $250,000 to play the game. Fans could not stop talking about the Black Knights' collapse, with reactions like "Army paid Tarleton State to come in and embarrass them."
Last season, the Army squad, which had an impressive record of 12-2 and was ranked as high as #21, faced significant challenges. They struggled with three turnovers in the second half, including two interceptions thrown by quarterback Dewayne Coleman. Additionally, they committed five penalties, a surprising outcome for a team that had been the least penalized the previous year.
Coleman, in only his second career start, displayed moments of brilliance, accumulating 129 passing yards and another 112 yards on the ground. However, his performance was inconsistent, and he left the game late in regulation due to an injury. Cale Hellums entered the game in his place and managed to score his first career touchdown, but ultimately, it wasn’t enough to secure a win.
Kicker Dawson Jones missed a 43-yard field goal that could have won the game in regulation, as well as a 35-yard attempt in overtime. In contrast, Tarleton State's Brad Larson successfully made a 37-yard field goal to secure the victory in the second overtime. This loss marked Army's first FCS upset since their defeat to Fordham in 2015, prompting fans to take to X to express their frustration and disappointment.
Tarleton State has no respect for the troops
— Bussin' With The Boys (@BussinWTB) August 30, 2025
They take down Army in 2OT pic.twitter.com/95WTn0dPMJ
Finally some chaos!! FCS member Tarleton State upsets Army 30-27 in 2 OT. Tarleton was 14 1/2 point underdog https://t.co/xmijZJHnjZ
— Brett McMurphy (@Brett_McMurphy) August 30, 2025
TARLETON STATE TAKES DOWN ARMY ON THE ROAD
— FOX College Football (@CFBONFOX) August 30, 2025
THE FIRST FCS OVER FBS UPSET OF THE SEASON pic.twitter.com/FEH5BeWGiC
Army paid Tarleton State $250K for the two to play in a game the Black Knights were supposed to win.
— Andrew Powell (@AndrewPow3ll) August 30, 2025
They went on to suffer a 30-27 upset loss, and though I hate it for our military, this is so college football.
Here's my latest from the Daily Caller: https://t.co/OcTcWhIqbt
Week One Finals for #TheAmerican Football. A few stick out. Obviously the lopsided FAU loss. Rice slipping past Louisiana. Despite the loss, UTSA hanging around with Texas A&M for a good chunk of the contest. And lastly, Army dropping a guarantee game to Tarleton State. pic.twitter.com/oBCD1FrU7J
— FAU Owls Nest (@FAU_Owls_Nest) August 31, 2025
Army football fans up in arms after upset loss to Tarleton State https://t.co/LsddLPtwFN #CollegeFootball
— Go Team Sports Network (@GoTeamSportsNet) August 30, 2025
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!