Three Quarterbacks, One Job — BYU’s Race Under Center Heats Up

BYU’s quarterback competition remains wide open as fall camp continues, with offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick offering insight into what each contender brings to the table.

The Cougars enter 2025 looking for stability at the position after Jake Retzlaff’s departure, and Roderick says each option has shown promise.

On sophomore McCae Hillstead, Roderick noted significant growth from spring to now. “He’s operating quicker than spring, very comfortable in the offense,” Roderick said. “I want him to push the tempo.” Hillstead’s command of the system and ability to speed up the pace could be a key asset for an offense looking to keep defenses off balance.

Junior Treyson Bourguet drew praise for his grasp of the playbook. “He knows the offense the best of the three,” Roderick said, while emphasizing the need for more consistency in execution. Bourguet’s familiarity with the system could give him an early edge, but sustaining performance will be critical to securing the job.

True freshman Bear Bachmeier has also impressed in his first camp with the program. “Very talented, very smart,” Roderick said. “I want to see him get more reps with the best players. He’s right in the mix.” Bachmeier’s combination of physical tools and football IQ has quickly put him into legitimate contention despite his inexperience.

With no timeline set for a decision, BYU appears content to let the competition play out deep into camp. The Cougars open the season against Portland State before diving into a challenging Big 12 slate.

Whichever quarterback emerges will inherit an offense that must improve its scoring output to compete in the league. For now, Roderick sees a battle where “the cream of the crop” will rise, and all three remain firmly in the running.