Sports Illustrated, once the most venerated media brand in all of sports, is the latest stage of the battle between man and machine. Or at least between writer and predictive technology.
The outlet, currently owned by The Arena Group, has discovered to have used artificial intelligence (AI) to produce some of its articles, even going so far as to have AI-generated profiles of writers who did not exist in real life.
All of this is according to a stunning report from Futurism's Maggie Harrison, who wrote that the fake profiles could be found for sale at a brokerage that sells AI-generated profiles. The outlet immediately deleted the profiles and articles in question, but not before Harrison's interrogation led to her report:
"The AI content marks a staggering fall from grace for Sports Illustrated, which in past decades won numerous National Magazine Awards for its sports journalism and published work by literary giants ranging from William Faulkner to John Updike.
"But now that it's under the management of The Arena Group, parts of the magazine seem to have devolved into a Potemkin Village in which phony writers are cooked up out of thin air, outfitted with equally bogus biographies and expertise to win readers' trust, and used to pump out AI-generated buying guides that are monetized by affiliate links to products that provide a financial kickback when readers click them."
The SI Union, which represents the editorial staff, posted its response to the expose on social media:
Our response to today’s story from @futurism reporting that The Arena Group has published AI-written stories by fake people under the Sports Illustrated name: pic.twitter.com/QcR4iGOi5w
— Sports Illustrated Union (@si_union) November 27, 2023
SI itself posted an explanation of the practice, essentially casting blame on AdVon Commerce, a third party hired by The Arena Group to produce the articles:
Today, an article was published alleging that Sports Illustrated published AI-generated articles. According to our initial investigation, this is not accurate.
— Sports Illustrated (@SInow) November 27, 2023
The articles in question were product reviews and were licensed content from an external, third-party company, AdVon…
In a time where talk around artificial intelligence can sound hysteric — from either its biggest champions or loudest critics — the discovery of what's happening at SI has served to further put a spotlight on the latest economic challenges faced by writers of all fields.
Much of the conversation around both the Hollywood writers' (WGA) and actors' (SAG-AFTRA) strikes this year was focused on the advent of AI. Both camps feared that production studios and media companies would use the growing technologies to create stories without human nuance and skill and even use the likeness of actors without their permission through tricky legalese.
Sports Illustrated itself has struggled mightily with bringing its venerated style online over much of the past two decades. During the blog era of the 2000s, established outlets such as SI waged battles with newer (and often more diverse) voices that didn't take traditional paths into the media world.
Inevitably as those established outlets lost market share, they began to adopt online platforms they once shunned, to varied levels of success and, at times, much controversy.
SI has also gone through two ownership changes in the last five years - first from Time Warner to Meredith in 2018, then to theMaven just one year later.
Rebranded as The Arena Group, the current parent company has done all it could to license the brand of Sports Illustrated into travel and retail clothing. Yet this latest tactic has sent shudders through the industry as well as sports fans who still appreciate the written word.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!