Blue Jays Facing Anthony Santander Decision After Bo Bichette News

Ahead of Wednesday’s series-clinching game against New York, Bichette was seen on the field running for the first time since suffering the sprain, signaling he had finally progressed to the final hurdle of his rehab. “I've made some huge progress the last few days. I'm really optimistic about where I stand,” Bichette said during Toronto’s celebration on Wednesday (h/t Shi Davidi of Sportsnet). “I'll do everything I can to get ready. I have a positive mindset, for sure.”

As Bichette does everything he can to prepare for the ALCS roster, the Blue Jays may face a difficult decision on who to leave off to make room, and Anthony Santander could be the odd man out. If Bichette returns, the team could shift him to designated hitter instead of shortstop to limit his defensive workload. Bichette’s value is primarily at the plate, as he does not grade out well defensively at shortstop (-13 Outs Above Average). A move to DH would push George Springer back into the outfield, forcing Toronto to choose an outfield bat to remove from the roster.

While Myles Straw is a candidate, his elite speed and defense give him an edge that Santander does not offer. Santander has had a disappointing first season in Toronto after signing a five-year, $92.5 million deal in the offseason. He spent extended time on the injured list and struggled to produce when healthy.

With Bichette’s return a realistic possibility, Santander’s roster spot may hinge on whether the Blue Jays prioritize upside at the plate or reliability in the field.