Luis Arraez’s Scary Collision Sparks Safety Talk

Arraez is now on the seven day injured list and is progressing through MLB’s concussion protocols. Thankfully, CT scans revealed no structural damage to his neck or jaw, and he’s testing well cognitively. While Arraez’s injury didn’t result in the worst-case scenario, it has sparked a broader discussion on player safety. The incident has raised questions about whether MLB should implement additional measures to protect players from such collisions, with some suggesting rule changes or safety innovations to prevent similar situations in the future.

Short-Handed Padres Feel the Impact of Luis Arraez’s Absence

Short on infielders, the Padres recalled Mason McCoy in a corresponding move. Still, Arraez’s absence looms large as San Diego continues to grapple with a wave of injuries. Five players from their Opening Day lineup: Arraez, Jake Cronenworth, Jackson Merrill, Brandon Lockridge, and Jason Heyward have now landed on the injured list. Four of the injured players are left-handed hitters, leaving the Padres without much of their usual left-right lineup balance.

As the Padres hope for a quick return from Arraez, the bigger question remains: is it time for a double first base?

Should MLB Adopt the Double First Base Rule?

One suggestion gaining traction comes from college baseball: the “double first base” rule. The NCAA uses two separate bases, one for the runner and one for the defender. This helps reduce collisions on close plays as it’s a simple concept with potentially big implications.

“I wouldn’t be opposed to it,” said Shildt on his appearance on Starkville, part of The Athletic’s The Windup podcast.

“I haven’t seen it or played with it, to form a real strong opinion. But conceptually, it’s one of those things where you go: You know, why not? I mean, we want our players to be safe and on the field, so I don’t really see a huge reason (not to).

“Conceptually, it does check some boxes to me that make sense — that listen, let’s just create a lane for everybody.”

Shildt has acknowledged MLB’s recent efforts to improve baserunning safety including clarifying the running lane rules. However, he sees potential in going further by saying “I don’t see why not,”. He supports the idea of implementing a double first base. Shildt believes it could enhance player safety without compromising the integrity of the game. He sees no downside, suggesting it aligns with MLB’s goals of keeping players healthy and could help prevent injuries like the one Arraez suffered.