To be among the top second basemen in today’s game requires being adept at more than just one or two facets of the game. You cannot just get on base regularly or steal a ton of bases. At the same time, it takes more than just elite glove work or the ability to hit the ball over the fence habitually. Today’s top-tier second sackers bring a lot to the table, and many do the heaviest lifting for their respective clubs.
While reigning AL MVP Jose Altuve’s shadow (ironically) looms large over the position, the competition at the top is strong. Brian Dozier has established himself as one of the most well-rounded players in the game in Minnesota, while Robinson Cano’s consistency has endured and keeps Seattle inching toward an ever-elusive postseason berth. Meanwhile, the future of the position continues to impress, as Jonathan Schoop, Javy Baez and Whit Merrifield move along their growth curves.
The scene is solid among the top second basemen in the game. Let's dissect the top 10 at the position headed into the spring of 2018.
10. Jed Lowrie, Athletics. The journeyman’s strong 2017 effort went largely unnoticed in the abyss of Oakland, but it was an impressive output all the same. His 49 doubles were the second most in the AL, while his 4.0 WAR was a career best and checked in sixth among MLB second basemen.
Combined with his always solid glove play and ability to shift to third base if needed, Lowrie could be a popular in-season trade target if he can remain at this level for another year.
9. Javy Baez, Cubs. Baez is one of the most enticing and exciting players in the game, and there is so much more to come. On the heels of a breakout showing as a major part in propelling the Cubs to the 2016 World Series, he became a mainstay in the everyday lineup wherever Joe Maddon could work him in. This included over 70 games at both shortstop and second base, along with time at both corner infield slots and in right field as well.
Regardless of where he carried his glove, Baez continued to grow at the plate, raising his OPS by nearly 60 points from the year before in about the same amount of games played. He also topped 20 homers, 20 doubles, 75 runs scored and 75 RBI while reaching double digits in stolen bases for the second straight year as well. While he continues to gain greater plate discipline, he will begin to see even better pitches to work with.
8. Whit Merrifield, Royals. A year after being a surprise AL Rookie of the Year finalist for the Royals as a utility man, Merrifield affirmed himself at second base in his sophomore season. He slashed .288/.324/.460/.784 on the year, while leading the AL in stolen bases with 34. The most encouraging outcome regarding his overall potential, however, came in the big surge in power he showed. After connecting for only two long balls in 322 plate appearances as a rookie, Merrifield knocked out 19 on the year in less than 300 more at-bats. He may be a sleeper candidate for a 30/30 season in the future.
7. Scooter Gennett, Reds. Perhaps 2017's biggest and most unlikely breakout was Gennett's, who transformed himself after being released from the Brewers in March. Maybe it was the motivation of the release, or maybe it was making his way back to his hometown. Whatever the case, Gennett became a different man, raising his slugging percentage nearly 120 points on the back of a 27-home run breakout. This genesis was highlighted by a four-homer, 10-RBI night in June. All in all, he led all NL second basemen in home runs and RBI.
6. DJ LeMahieu, Rockies. LeMahieu’s greatest value is not one specific overwhelming impact; rather, it is his remarkable ability to stay consistent. His .310 average in 2017 marked the third consecutive year he topped .300. Over past two seasons, his split line sits at a surprisingly strong .328/.394/.450 with an average of 30 doubles, 100 runs scored and 65 RBI. Combine that with his elite defense at second — LeMahieu led the NL in fielding percentage, range factor and double plays turned at second en route to his third Gold Glove — and you have one of the most underrated players in the game.
5. Robinson Cano, Mariners. As he enters his age 35 season, it is time to appreciate the level at which Cano has remained as time moves along. While he did not equal the 7.3 WAR level he performed at in 2016, he still finished among the upper rungs of AL second basemen in doubles (33) and RBI (97).
As for the legacy discussion, Cano is beginning to be mentioned among the greats of all-time at the position. His .305 career average is seventh best among second basemen, while his 512 doubles have him only 30 behind passing Rogers Hornsby for fifth-most ever at the position. After passing 300 home runs late in 2017, he is also on pace to topple 2,500 hits for his career this summer.
4. Daniel Murphy, Nationals. Murphy is entering the final season of his three-year deal with the Nationals, which stands to be one of the biggest bang-for-the-buck contracts ever. In his two years in D.C. thus far, Murphy has twice led the NL in doubles with a total of 90. His .928 2017 OPS included 43 doubles, 23 home runs and a .322/.384/.543 split line. Even if he has a slightly lowered output in 2018, the two-time Silver Slugger winner has more than made good on the $37.5 million pact he signed in Washington.
3. Jonathan Schoop, Orioles. Quietly, Schoop has put together a rapid rise in the hierarchy of second basemen. In a 2017 season that saw him make his All-Star debut, Schoop hit 32 homers, drove in 105 runs, scored 92 runs and had an .841 OPS. Although he did strike out 142 times, many of the steady improvements in his game have come in large part due to a maturing approach at the plate. With Manny Machado likely entering his final year in Baltimore, Schoop is clearly the heir apparent as the franchise player for the O’s — at least until he reaches free agency himself.
2. Brian Dozier, Twins. A jack of all trades, Dozier followed up his breakout 2016 power performance with another brilliant all-around effort in 2017. He again topped 30 home runs, 90 RBI and 15 stolen bases, while crossing the plate more than 100 times for the fourth straight year. He also won his first Gold Glove in the process.
Entering the final year of his contract, it will be interesting to see how the Twins handle the decision to hold on to or move Dozier. After playing such a big part of their historic turnaround a year ago, if the Twins stay in the race again, it will be hard to justify moving him despite the likely high interest in his services across the league.
1. Jose Altuve, Astros
Altuve is the most relentless talent in the game and in a class completely of his own at the position. En route to leading Houston to its first World Series title, Altuve affirmed that he is the most unique elite player in the game’s history. He continues to put the pressure on as the best combination of contact and speed in the game. Altuve led the American League in hits for the fourth straight year in 2017, making him the first player ever to do so outright. Since 2014, he has averaged 219 hits per 162 games. Meanwhile, his increased power has not taken away his ability to keep up the pressure on the base paths, as his 32 stolen bases marked the sixth straight year he has topped 30 thefts.
Along the way, he continued to display a surprising amount of power, reaching 24 homers for the second straight year, while raising his OPS to a career-best .957 and scoring a career-high 112 runs. When the dust all settled, he led the majors with an 8.3 WAR, won his third batting title in four years (.346) and pulled away with AL MVP honors. If his regular-season exploits were not enough, he connected for seven more postseason home runs, including a pair of crucial shots against Chris Sale.
Left on deck: Starlin Castro (Marlins), Joe Panik (Giants), Dustin Pedroia (Red Sox), Cesar Hernandez (Phillies), Ian Kinsler (Angels)
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
New York Yankees star Aaron Judge is undergoing tests due to a lingering elbow issue. Yankees manager Aaron Boone said Saturday that Judge will be held out of the lineup as he goes for imaging on his elbow, per Joel Sherman of the New York Post. The manager did not offer any indication of how serious the injury was. Notably, Judge could be seen grimacing after making a throw during Tuesday’s game against the Toronto Blue Jays. At the time, the Yankees downplayed the issue and suggested Judge would feel better after a scheduled off-day. The Yankees obviously cannot go without Judge for any extended period of time. The 33-year-old is having a historically great season, hitting .342 with 37 home runs. He also missed significant time in 2023, but has otherwise been able to stay healthy over the past several seasons. Judge’s injury issue comes at a delicate time for the Yankees, who sit 5.5 games back of the Blue Jays in the AL East. They do lead the AL Wild Card race, but only by 2.5 games, so they are hardly assured of a playoff spot. If Judge misses time, their status gets even shakier.
Now in her second WNBA season, Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese is averaging a league‑leading 12.5 rebounds along with 13.8 points, 3.7 assists and 1.4 steals per game. She recently returned from injury and immediately picked up where she left off, posting her 16th double‑double of the season (11 points, 11 rebounds) on Tuesday night even as her Chicago Sky fell, 91-68, to the Minnesota Lynx. Then, on Wednesday, Reese showcased her brand power on Instagram, posting a pregame photo dressed head‑to‑toe in Gucci with the caption, "Don’t worry about me… life is GUCCI @gucci #guccipartner." The image quickly lit up her feed and drew an immediate response from one of the game’s all‑time greats, WNBA legend Lisa Leslie, who commented, “Yessss it is❤️." Despite flashes of elite play, the Sky have struggled mightily, standing at just 7-17 and sitting fifth in the Eastern Conference. Their 76.7 points per game rank 12th in the WNBA, and opponents are torching them for 86.8 a night (12th in the league). With head coach Tyler Marsh searching for consistency, every bright spot has been a welcome reprieve for a franchise that won the title as recently as 2021. Front and center among Chicago’s bright spots is Reese. Off the court, Reese has quickly built a burgeoning portfolio of endorsement deals, including Reebok, Calvin Klein, Beats by Dre, Amazon and now Gucci, underscoring her status as one of the WNBA’s brightest personalities. On the other side, you have Leslie, whose voice carries more weight than arguably anybody in women’s basketball. A three‑time league MVP, two‑time WNBA champion and Finals MVP and eight‑time All‑Star, Leslie helped define the league’s early years with the Los Angeles Sparks, including driving home the first dunk in WNBA history in 2002. A Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Famer (class of 2015), she remains a global ambassador for the sport.
Adam Fox is highly regarded around the NHL, but according to a stray from Oilers reporter Jim Matheson, he's not quite a top-five defenseman in the NHL. The rankings of defenseman around the NHL have become a major talking point in recent years, and while Cale Makar and Quinn Hughes are highly regarded as the top two defensemen in the league, beyond that, there's plenty of room for debate. Other names like Adam Fox, Zach Werenski, Rasmus Dahlin, Victor Hedman and Jaccob Slavin are all in the mix as well, but now, a top Edmonton Oilers reporter in Jim Matheson has made a ridiculous statement. When addressing a ranking that was brought up on social media, the Edmonton Journal reporter stated that Fox was absolutely not a top-five defenseman in the league, even if it's a widely accepted ranking at this point in time. Even in what was considered a down year on one of the NHL's most disappointing teams, Fox managed to put up 10 goals and 61 points in 74 games played along with a +9 differential, as he once again solidified himself as a top defenseman in the league. Of course, the duo of Makar and Hughes are head and shoulders above the rest, but over the past six seasons, Fox has been one of the most consistently brilliant players in the NHL, and whether the team struggles or dominates, he's in the middle of any success. Ultimately, Matheson is likely bringing up his feelings due to the 'disrespect' of Evan Bouchard, who many in Edmonton believe is a top defenseman in the NHL, but widely, he simply isn't, and that's led to Fox catching a surprise stray.
The Washington Commanders are a close-knit squad. Everyone is on the same page and pulling in the same direction in pursuit of one common goal. And the veterans have no trouble lending their support to fledgling stars looking for increased responsibilities. One piece of heartfelt advice is fueling a potential breakout candidate for bigger and better things. And based on the early results at training camp, it's having the desired effect. Washington is giving second-year defensive back Tyler Owens all he can handle over the early stages of camp. The former undrafted free agent is getting first-team reps in the nickel and at the safety spot. He doesn't look out of place, which bodes well for his chances of additional involvement in 2025. Tyler Owens leaning on Commanders veterans in pursuit of increased role in 2025 Owens isn't shy when it comes to seeking advice from those with far more NFL experience. Jeremy Reaves is among them, and the All-Pro special teamer lifted the lid on the industry secrets he's passed on to his teammate this offseason. Man, just slow down, take a deep breath. Understanding that football is the same concept at all levels, it's just spoken differently, and it's done a little differently, is important, but football is football. You're a heck of a player; you're a freak athlete. Let that do the work for you. If you train your mind, your body will follow, so I just tell him that and he's getting more and more of an understanding. Now he's just going out there and playing, so I'm excited for him because I've seen the growth, and that's the most important part of it.Jeremy Reaves via Commanders.com The Texas Tech product has been all ears, and he's putting these tidbits to good use. Owens looks more comfortable in the defensive scheme. He's always had exceptional athleticism, but the Commanders are starting to see more from the player now that the game is slowing down for him. This is a massive positive from Owens' perspective. He emerged as a training camp star last summer en route to making the 53-man roster. An injury stunted his progress, but the flashes on special teams and being around the squad should serve him well in Year 2. What comes next is down to Owens. He's giving himself a fighting chance of being a bigger part of Joe Whitt Jr.'s strategy this season. And if he achieves this objective, one couldn't dismiss the possibility of him becoming a long-term piece of Washington's defensive puzzle. Owens has every athletic intangible needed to be successful. And having such a strong veteran support system is only helping his cause. More Commanders news and analysis