Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
20 MLB players who were one-season wonders
TED MATHIAS/AFP via Getty Images

20 MLB players who were one-season wonders

The music business has one-hit wonders. On the baseball diamond, we have one-season wonders: players who put together a memorable year and then were either unable to build off that time or were essentially never heard from again.

Here's our list (in chronological order) of some of the more notable one-season wonders in Major League Baseball history.

 
1 of 20

Bill James, P (1914)

Bill James, P (1914)
Bettmann/Contributor/Getty Images

We are not talking about the king of sabermetrics, but instead the man known as "Seattle Bill,"  not to be confused with his contemporary "Big" Bill James. This James spent just four seasons with the Boston Braves. He won 37 games during his tenure, with practically all coming during his stellar 26-7 season of 1914. That year, he struck out 156 batters over 332 and 1/3 innings while posting a 1.90 ERA en route to helping the Braves win the World Series.

 
2 of 20

Cito Gaston, OF (1970)

Cito Gaston, OF (1970)
John Cordes/Icon Sportswire

Gaston managed the Toronto Blue Jays to back-to-back World Series titles (1992 and '93), but he also had a 12-year playing career. His best season came in 1970 with San Diego, when he clubbed 29 homers and drove in 93 runs while batting .318. However, even with two more double-digit home run seasons, Gaston never came near that kind of success or hit over .300 again.

 
3 of 20

Billy Grabarkewitz, 3B (1970)

Billy Grabarkewitz, 3B (1970)
Focus on Sport/Getty Images

In just his second season on the big-league level, Grabarkewitz made his only All-Star appearance while with the Los Angeles Dodgers. He hit .289 and posted a .399 on-base percentage while also belting 17 home runs and driving in 84 runs. That promise Grabarkewitz showed in '70 was short-lived. He totaled just 11 home runs and never hit better than .288 while playing five more seasons. 

 
4 of 20

Mark Fidrych (1976)

Mark Fidrych (1976)
Focus on Sport/Getty Images

"The Bird" remains one of the greatest characters in baseball history. From talking to the ball to his colorful mound antics , he was truly one of a kind. And for one season, in 1976, not many pitched better than Fidrych. He went 19-9 with a 2.34 ERA in 31 games — 29 starts — to win the AL Rookie of the Year while with the Detroit Tigers. Injuries, however, kept Fidrych from building on that special season, and he won 10 games while pitching just 27 over the next four seasons before his career came to an end.

 
5 of 20

Wayne Garland, P (1976)

Wayne Garland, P (1976)
Sporting News via Getty Images

When Garland was given a real shot with Baltimore in 1976, he made the most of it. The right-hander went 20-7 with a 2.67 ERA over 38 games and 25 starts. It's still one of the best pitching seasons in major league history and earned Garland a 10-year deal with Cleveland, beginning in '77. Garland, however, was never able to build on that season, losing 19 games in 1977 and suffering significant arm issues that led to relatively poor results. Cleveland fans chided Garland for not living up to his contract that was worth $2.3 million, and he was out of the majors by 1982. 

 
6 of 20

Joe Charboneau, OF (1980)

Joe Charboneau, OF (1980)
Rich Pilling/MLB Photos/Getty Images

Though Charboneau's career lasted just three seasons, all with Cleveland, he's still revered by Indians fans to this day. The power-hitting Charboneau clubbed 23 home runs and had 87 RBIs while batting .289 to win AL Rookie of the Year honors in 1980. Sadly for Charboneau, that was essentially it for his career. A back problem had a major role in him playing just 70 games over the next two seasons, and he never saw action in the majors after that. Interesting note: Charboneau was an extra in the Robert Redford classic "The Natural."

 
7 of 20

Jerome Walton, CF (1989)

Jerome Walton, CF (1989)
Focus on Sport/Getty Images

Part of the Chicago Cubs daily double with Dwight Smith in 1989, Walton won NL Rookie of the Year honors for the division winners that year. Walton recorded 23 doubles, 46 RBI and batted .293 at the top of the Cubs order. The potential for greatness Walton showed that season never materialized, though, and while he played until 1998, was a middling player at best.

 
8 of 20

Kevin Maas, 1B/DH (1990)

Kevin Maas, 1B/DH (1990)
J Giamundo/Bruce Bennett Studios/Getty Images

For a spell in the early 1990s, Maas was revered like other Yankee greats for the hot start to his career, and was even considered to be the next Don Mattingly. As a rookie in 1990, Maas hit 21 home runs, had 41 RBI and posted an OPS of .902 in just 79 games. He needed only 72 at-bats to hit 10 homers. There were big things expected from Maas going forward, but though he went deep 23 times over 148 games in 1991, he fanned 128 and batted .220. A year later, Maas could not hold down a full-time job in the majors and played his last big league game on June 20, 1995.

 
9 of 20

Dave Fleming, P (1992)

Dave Fleming, P (1992)
Otto Greule/Allsport/Getty Images

While Fleming pitched in just six major-league seasons, his rookie year of 1992 will not be forgotten by Seattle Mariners fans. The left-hander went 17-10 with a 3.39 ERA and won nine consecutive decisions early in that campaign. Fleming did win 12 games a year later, but increased arm issues had him out of the majors after the 1995 season.

 
10 of 20

Phil Plantier, OF (1993)

Phil Plantier, OF (1993)
Andy Hayt/San Diego Padres/Getty Images

Plantier should be lauded for a solid rookie season for Boston in 1991, when he slammed 11 homers in 53 games and batted .331. However, he struggled the next season and ended up in San Diego, where in 1993, Plantier set career highs with 34 home runs and 100 RBI. Injuries followed, though, and Plantier never came close to that '93 success even though he played until 1997.

 
11 of 20

Rick Wilkins, C (1993)

Rick Wilkins, C (1993)
Stephen Dunn/Staff/Getty Images

Wilkins' stellar 1993 season with the Cubs is still considered one of the best by a catcher in MLB history. With 30 homers and a .303 batting average, Wilkins became the fourth catcher at the time to knock at least 30 home runs and hit .300 or better. Unfortunately for Wilkins, he posted just one more double-digit homer year and never came close to .300 again before his career ended after 2001.

 
12 of 20

Tuffy Rhodes, CF (1994)

Tuffy Rhodes, CF (1994)
Jonathan Daniel/Allsport/Getty Images

OK, this is more of a one-game wonder, and maybe a half-season at best, since Rhodes was hitting in the .270s by late May and did belt eight of his career 13 home runs in 1994. But many won't forget his three-home run season opener off Dwight Gooden that year. It's perhaps the best opening day performance in major league history.  

 
13 of 20

Bob Hamelin, DH (1994)

Bob Hamelin, DH (1994)
Ted Mathias/AFP/Getty Images

Hamelin was 26 years old when he won the AL Rookie of the Year award in 1994 for the Kansas City Royals. Hamelin set what would become career highs of 24 homers, 65 RBI and a .282 average while posting an OPS of .987. Leg issues, however, plagued Hamelin and he was out of Kansas City after the 1996 season. He jacked 18 home runs for Detroit in '97, but his days in the majors ended after the '98 campaign.

 
14 of 20

Brady Anderson, OF (1996)

Brady Anderson, OF (1996)
Staff/Icon Sportswire

Anderson spent 15 years in the majors, made three All-Star teams and is a member of the Baltimore Orioles Hall of Fame. However, he is best known for a 1996 season when he set career highs with 50 home runs — an Orioles team record — and 110 RBI while batting .297. Since Anderson never hit more than 21 home runs in each his previous eight seasons — and not more than 24 in any of his six that followed —  allegations of performance-enhancing drug use was associated with Anderson's tremendous season and remains an asterisk on his career.

 
15 of 20

Justin Thompson, P (1997)

Justin Thompson, P (1997)
Sporting News via Getty Images

A first-round pick out of high school in 1991, Thompson did not make his big league debut until 1996. The next year he went 15-11 with a 3.02 ERA while striking out 151 batters for the Detroit Tigers, and he earned an All-Star trip. It was a career season for Thompson, who went 11-15 with a 4.05 ERA in 1998. Injuries eventually led to the left-hander spending most of the first half of the 2000s in the minors before calling it a career in May 2006

 
16 of 20

Warren Morris, 2B (1999)

Warren Morris, 2B (1999)
Matthew Stockman/Allsport/Getty Images

The College World Series hero from LSU, Morris looked to be in for big things on the major league-level thanks to a strong rookie campaign. In '99, Morris worked his way into the starting lineup and batted .288 with 15 homers, 20 doubles and 73 RBI. However, by 2004, Morris was out the majors after following his rookie season with just 11 RBI the rest of his career. 

 
17 of 20

Fernando Tatis, 3B (1999)

Fernando Tatis, 3B (1999)
Sporting News via Getty Images

Tatis' 1999 season was special, not only because he set career highs with 34 home runs and 107 RBI for the St. Louis Cardinals, but also for hitting two grand slams in one inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers on April 23 of that year. Tatis played 11 seasons in the bigs but never hit more than 18 homers in a year or posted better than 64 RBI before or after 1999. 

 
18 of 20

Esteban Loaiza, P (2003)

Esteban Loaiza, P (2003)
Mark Goldman/Icon Sportswire

Loaiza spent a serviceable 14 seasons in the majors and was a two-time All-Star. By far, his best season came in 2003 with the Chicago White Sox when he went 21-9 with a 2.90 ERA while leading the majors with 207 strikeouts. By that time, the right-hander was on his fourth team and the thought was he would consistently shine for at least a few more years. They were solid but nothing close to what he accomplished in '03.

 
19 of 20

Bobby Crosby, SS (2004)

Bobby Crosby, SS (2004)
Ric Tapia/Icon Sportswire

Crosby played eight seasons in the majors, mostly with the Oakland Athletics. Though he saw action in 11 games in 2003, Crosby won the AL Rookie of the Year award in 2004 for clubbing 22 home runs while recording 130 hits, 34 doubles and 64 RBI. Crosby, however, never hit more than nine home runs in any other season but did have a decent 2008 campaign for the A's. Yet the star Oakland thought it had in 2004 never really panned out. 

 
20 of 20

Bryan LaHair, 1B/OF (2012)

Bryan LaHair, 1B/OF (2012)
Jeanine Leech/Icon Sportswire

While there is a good chance many have forgotten the name Bryan LaHair, even more probably don't remember he made the NL All-Star team in 2012. After totaling five homers and 16 RBI over 65 games in two MLB seasons prior to his breakout, LaHair went deep 16 times and drove home 40 runs while slugging .450 in 130 contests for the Chicago Cubs in '12. That, however, proved to be LaHair's last season in the majors.  

Jeff Mezydlo

A Chicago native, Jeff Mezydlo has professionally written about sports, entertainment and pop culture for parts of four decades. He was an integral member of award-winning sports sections at The Times of Northwest Indiana (Munster, Ind. ) and Champaign (Ill

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Craig Kimbrel lands with World Series contender after latest release
MLB

Craig Kimbrel lands with World Series contender after latest release

Craig Kimbrel is hoping to make an impact with an MLB team down the stretch, and a World Series contender is giving the former All-Star reliever a shot. Kimbrel agreed to a big-league contract with the Houston Astros on Thursday, according to ESPN's Jeff Passan. Kimbrel began the 2025 season with the Atlanta Braves after signing a minor-league contract with them in March. The right-hander started out with the Double-A Columbus Clingstones and did not give up a hit in three appearances. Kimbrel was then promoted to the Triple-A Gwinnett Stripers, where he went 1-1 with a 2.00 ERA and 23 strikeouts over 18 innings. The Braves added Kimbrel to their active roster on June 6. He pitched a scoreless seventh inning in Atlanta's 5-4 win over the San Francisco Giants that day. Kimbrel allowed a walk and a hit in the inning. The following day, Atlanta made the puzzling decision to designate Kimbrel for assignment. Kimbrel opted for free agency rather than accepting his minor league assignment. He then signed a minor league contract with the Texas Rangers but never made it to their MLB roster. Kimbrel was granted his release on Thursday and signed with Houston. Kimbrel, 37, is a nine-time All-Star who has pitched for eight different teams during his MLB career. He led the National League in saves four times and was one of the best relief pitchers in the league during his prime. Kimbrel also helped the Boston Red Sox win a World Series in 2018. The Astros were 69-58 entering Thursday and had a 1.5-game lead over the Seattle Mariners in the AL West. If Kimbrel is healthy, he could provide Houston with some valuable bullpen depth over the final stretch of the season.

Dallas Stars lock up one of the league's best players with massive extension today in hockey history
NHL

Dallas Stars lock up one of the league's best players with massive extension today in hockey history

The Dallas Stars have had many defining moments in their history, but few symbolize loyalty and leadership like Mike Modano's contract extension in the early 2000s. On August 21, 2003, the Stars officially locked up their franchise icon with an extension that cemented his role as the face of hockey in Texas. The move wasn't just about keeping a superstar forward, it was about keeping the identity of the Stars firmly tied to one of the most respected players in the game. Mike Modano's extension showed his loyalty and lasting impact on the Dallas Stars At the time, speculation lingered about whether Modano might test the waters elsewhere. Instead, he reaffirmed his commitment to Dallas, the franchise that had drafted him first overall back in 1988 when they were still the Minnesota North Stars. "This team, this city, it means everything to me. Staying here was the only choice that felt right," Modano said during the press conference announcing the deal. Those words resonated with fans, as his decision represented stability during an era when star players often left in search of bigger contracts. The extension also ensured that Modano would continue climbing the NHL record books in a Stars uniform. He went on to become the all-time American-born leader in goals and points, a record that defined his Hall of Fame career. Looking back, the August 21 signing stands as a cornerstone moment in Dallas Stars history. I think it was one of the smartest moves the franchise ever made, keeping Modano in green not only secured wins on the ice but also preserved a legacy that still inspires players today.

Former Yankees Outfielder Rips Aaron Boone, Brian Cashman
General Sports

Former Yankees Outfielder Rips Aaron Boone, Brian Cashman

The New York Yankees have been having a rough couple of months, losing their once-dominant lead of the AL East. Now, both Yankees manager Aaron Boone and general manager Brian Cashman are on the receiving end of some tough words by a former player, outfielder Clint Frazier. Boone has been criticized by a number of analysts (not to mention Yankees fans) for lineup and mid-game moves that range from head-scratching to downright bizarre, especially for a team that has been having a hard time securing wins. Cashman has repeatedly defended Boone, arguing that is knowledge of the players' capabilities is driving his decisions. To Frazier, Cashman's defense of Boone is self-serving because Cashman is the person who is responsible for Boone's tenure as manager. “When Cashman comes out and gives support to Boone, lowkey, I kind of feel like that’s self-preservation,” Frazier said on his podcast. “I know his resume is insane, but when he gives the confidence boost to Boone, I was saying ‘he’s got to, because Booney is the frontline of defense for him. I brought this guy in, and I have to support him, because he’s my guy.' Boone is Cashman’s shadow a little bit." Frazier, who played for the Pinstripes from 2017 to 2021, went on to discuss the Yankees' playoff chances, criticizing Boone for his lineup and mid-game decisions, which he claims will impact the team negatively during the post-season. “You need to make sure that you aren’t walking into it with bad decisions, because these are the decisions they’ll be doing in the playoffs,” he said. “They’re going to be way more under the microscope in the playoffs... You’ve got to make sure that you’re buttoned up and ready to go. If you start firing from the hip, it becomes a mockery of what every guy is trying to do.” While the Yankees are doing better now than they were at the time of Frazier's comments, surpassing the Boston Red Sox for second place in the AL East and securing the top spot in the AL Wild Card standings, they still aren't consistent. For New York to secure a trip to the World Series for the second year in a row, they're going to have to play better, which requires Boone to make better decisions. Make sure to bookmark Yankees On SI to get all your daily New York Yankees news, interviews, breakdowns and more! Yankees Have Advantage in Cody Bellinger Sweepstakes Former Yankees Pitchers Swap Places On NL Contender Hall of Famer Explains Leaving Red Sox for Yankees Mariano Rivera's Injury End of Yankees Old-Timer's Game? Four Yankees Among MLB's Top 25 Free Agents

Falcons HC speaks out after offensive starter gets carted off practice field with concerning injury
NFL

Falcons HC speaks out after offensive starter gets carted off practice field with concerning injury

Atlanta Falcons head coach Raheem Morris announced that starting right tackle Kaleb McGary will miss “significant time” with a left leg injury suffered in Wednesday’s practice. "The thing I will say to you now is that he will miss significant time," Morris said after the Falcons' last preseason game in Dallas, per the team's official website. "Looks like it will be IR, whatever the case may be, we will have to see there, but he will miss significant time for us." McGary went down during individual drills and had to be carted off the field. Although Morris indicated that the six-year veteran will land on injured reserve, that could come with a return designation if the Falcons believe he can return this season. The 30-year-old just negotiated a $3.5M raise earlier this month with a two-year, $15M extension. With Michael Penix Jr. entering his first full season as a starter, McGary may have had some added leverage as the left-handed quarterback’s new blindside protector. McGary’s injury will stretch an already-injured tackle room even further. Swing tackle Storm Norton is recovering from ankle surgery and former UDFA Tyrone Wheatley Jr. is out for the year. If Norton isn’t ready for Week 1, it’s unclear who will start at right tackle. Morris specifically mentioned Elijah Wilkinson as a player who is expected to step up amid the injuries. He’s currently listed as the backup left guard on the Falcons’ unofficial depth chart, but the eight-year veteran moved to left tackle for the team’s second preseason. He also has 20 career starts at right tackle, though the last came in 2021. Brandon Parker is listed as Atlanta’s backup right tackle, but has lined up at left tackle in the preseason. Like Wilkinson, he has plenty of past experience at right tackle as well. Rookie Jack Nelson could also be a factor after starting both preseason games at right tackle, but the seventh-rounder may not be trusted to protect Penix’s blind side right away. If McGary and/or Norton begin the season on IR, UDFA Jordan Williams could make the roster as extra depth after getting a handful of snaps at right tackle in the preseason.