The reality behind Pete Crow-Armstrong’s low All‑Star voting

To begin with, All‑Star voting is as much about popularity and emotion as it is about performance. Fans vote for players who excite them, who represent hope, who make the season feel worth following.

Right now, the Cubs offer none of that.

Over the past two months, they’ve lost games in bunches, looked lifeless for long stretches, and watched their supposed stars underperform. As a result, the season has become a slog, and the fanbase has responded accordingly. When a team plays this poorly, fans don’t reward them with All‑Star votes — they disengage.

Consequently, PCA’s recent hot streak hasn’t been enough to overcome the broader apathy surrounding the team. This isn’t just about his numbers; it’s about the overall perception of the Cubs, which has clearly taken a hit.

His immaturity and persona angered non-Chicago fans

In addition, PCA is dealing with a self‑inflicted problem: his reputation.

The helmet tosses.
The bat throws.
The visible frustration after strikeouts.
The spat with a White Sox fan.
The comments about Dodgers fans being “casual.”

Taken together, these moments have painted a picture of immaturity — fair or not. And in a season where the Cubs already feel unlikable, PCA’s emotional outbursts have only reinforced the perception that this team lacks composure and accountability.

As a result, opposing fans have taken notice. And since they’re voters too, the backlash shows up in the standings.

To be clear, PCA’s talent is undeniable. His defense is elite, his athleticism jumps off the field, and his ceiling remains sky‑high. Yet despite his recent offensive surge, his bat hasn’t been consistent enough to demand national attention.

While it’s unlikely he climbs into a starting spot, there remains an outside chance he could make the All‑Star team if other players opt out. Even so, PCA’s current standing reflects two realities: How poorly the Cubs have played, and how he is being perceived outside Chicago.