x
Yankees' Catcher Considering Significant Change to Boost Lineup
Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images

To say that the New York Yankees lack offensive production from their catchers would be an understatement.

As of May 31, the Yankees' catching tandem of Austin Wells and J.C. Escarra are collectively hitting .184/.280/.279 with four home runs (all by Wells), 18 RBI, a 60 wRC+ and 0.5 fWAR; the latter two metrics rank 27th and 20th in MLB, respectively. The only reason why the WAR value isn't in the negatives is because of solid defense from the duo, particularly in pitch framing.

What hasn't helped the Yankees' catching predicament is the fact that both Wells and Escarra are left-handed batters. While this would seem like a plus with Yankee Stadium being notoriously friendly to left-handed hitters, this is negated by the aforementioned struggles by both and the lack of a platoon advantage for Aaron Boone to utilize. As a result, with the Yankees surely looking to buy once the trade deadline rolls around, a righty-hitting catcher is one of the items on their wish list.

But what if the Yankees can address this problem without getting another catcher? Escarra is looking to do just that by taking up switch-hitting.

J.C. Escarra Experimenting as a Switch-Hitter in Batting Practice

During Saturday's broadcast of the Bronx Bombers' game against the Athletics, Yankees play-by-play announcer Michael Kay revealed that Escarra is trying to become a switch-hitter and has begun taking swings from the right side during batting practice.

"So behind the plate is Escarra, and I had a conversation with him today. He's been working on becoming a switch-hitter," Kay said. "He's been taking batting practice right-handed, and I said, 'How come?' He said, 'Well, I do everything else right-handed. Mechanically, I feel very locked in right-handed, and everybody keeps saying we need a right-handed catcher. Maybe it could be me.'"

It is worth mentioning that Escarra has superior splits against left-handed pitching, even in a small sample size. In 130 career plate appearances against righties, the 31-year-old is slashing just .159/.254/.274 with a 51 wRC+. But against southpaws, Escarra is hitting .333/.364/.433 with a 122 wRC+ in 33 plate appearances.

Becoming a switch-hitter is a tremendously difficult task. The Yankees had the luxury of a switch-hitting catcher in Jorge Posada at the turn of the millennium, and the Seattle Mariners currently have one in Cal Raleigh. However, Tampa Bay Rays outfielder Cedric Mullins struggled immensely when he started his career as a switch-hitter, and eventually stuck with exclusively batting left-handed. Another noteworthy example is the Yankees' currently-injured outfielder Jasson Dominguez, who started this season in Triple-A with the intent of improving his right-handed swing.

Escarra is no stranger to beating the odds, though. Working a number of odds jobs such as Uber driving and substitute teaching while chasing his dream of becoming a big leaguer, he successfully made the Yankees' roster out of spring training in 2025. The task of becoming a switch-hitter will presumably be the next step in Escarra's evolution as a ballplayer.

The Yankees should still explore trading for a right-handed catcher, as it is a far more guaranteed option than relying on Escarra developing into a switch-hitting bat. But they should still let him give it a shot.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!