49ers should inquire for these Colts players immediately

San Francisco never really filled in the hole left behind by Buckner, who was traded by the Niners to the Colts for the 13^th pick in the 2020 draft. The pick who was supposed to be his replacement, Javon Kinlaw, only started 28 games in four seasons and was let go. Other replacements, like Arik Armstead, who the team chose over Buckner, left for a larger contract and big splashes like Javon Hargrave never panned out, causing a former strength to become a weakness.

Buckner maintained his pass-rushing dominance, being named a first-team All-Pro in 2020, yet has struggled with injuries in the past two seasons, but seems to be back on track, tallying four sacks in 2026. The 49ers, meanwhile, are missing Nick Bosa but have an effective pass-rush by committee. But how sustainable can that be deep into the season? This reunion would refill that hole, strengthen the line and help mentor the surging youth.

Meanwhile, the Niners’ offensive line has been the best it’s ever been, not allowing a sack until Week 5. Sure, a lot of it has to do with Brock Purdy’s elusiveness, but the O-line is a big reason for the team’s early success.

Second-year guard Connor Colby gave up both pocket sacks against the Seahawks and wasn’t at fault for the two sacks against the Commanders, but upgrading to a three-time All-Pro in Nelson and giving Colby more time to learn wouldn’t hurt at all.

Having Nelson and Trent Williams eliminating the left side of the field for Purdy to work his magic could finally bring a title back to the Bay.

This would be a costly deal, likely including a first-round pick and a Day 2 selection, if not more, but would be worth it if the team is lifting the Lombardi Trophy come February.