Yardbarker
x
Best QBs to not win the Super Bowl

Best QBs to not win the Super Bowl

This slideshow chronicles the 25 best quarterbacks in NFL history who never won a Super Bowl.

 
1 of 25

Ken Anderson

Ken Anderson
George Gojkovich / Getty Images

The 1981 NFL MVP, Anderson made four Pro Bowls with the Bengals and was the league's completion percentage leader three times. While he never won the big one as a player, Anderson was on the Steelers coaching staff when Pittsburgh won Super Bowl XLIII.

 
2 of 25

John Brodie

John Brodie
Focus on Sport

Before Joe Montana and Steve Young, Brodie was the quarterback synonymous with the 49ers. He played for the team from 1957-73 and made two Pro Bowls, winning the MVP in 1970. Following his football career, he competed in the Senior PGA Tour.

 
3 of 25

Daunte Culpepper

Daunte Culpepper
Doug Pensinger / Getty Images

Culpepper's prime in Minnesota was short but incredible, as any longtime fantasy football player can tell you. Leading an incredible Vikings offense that included Randy Moss, Cris Carter and Robert Smith, Culpepper made three Pro Bowls, two All-Pro selections and led the NFL in passing yards during the 2004 season. Culpepper also had 34 rushing touchdowns for his career.

 
Randall Cunningham
Mitchell Layton / Getty Images

The versatile Cunningham's impressive playing career included four Pro Bowls and two First-Team All-Pro designations. He had an impressive 82-52-1 regular-season record for his career and rushed for 4,928 yards and 35 touchdowns on top of his nearly 30,000 career passing yards.

 
5 of 25

Boomer Esiason

Boomer Esiason
Jonathan Daniel / Getty Images

Esiason had a solid career playing with four teams, making four Pro Bowls. He won the 1988 NFL MVP, a year in which his Bengals lost the Super Bowl to the 49ers. He ranks 24th all time in passing yards.

 
6 of 25

Dan Fouts

Dan Fouts
Focus on Sport

Fouts set passing yardage records in three consecutive years, from 1979-81, made six Pro Bowls and was First-Team All-Pro twice. He also won the 1982 AP Offensive Player of the Year and still ranks 17th all time in passing yards.

 
7 of 25

Roman Gabriel

Roman Gabriel
Vic Stein / Getty Images

Between his career with the Rams and Eagles, Gabriel made four Pro Bowls and threw for 29,444 yards. His career passing yardage total still ranks 52nd all time.

 
8 of 25

Rich Gannon

Rich Gannon
Jed Jacobsohn / Getty Images

Gannon's time as a starter in the NFL was limited but quite productive when he did get his chance. Finally getting a shot late in his career with Kansas City, he parlayed a partial year of success into a big contract with Oakland and ended up making four Pro Bowls, being named First-Team All-Pro twice and winning the 2002 MVP. He did quarterback the Raiders in one Super Bowl, a loss to Tampa bay, and likely would have made another if not for the legendary tuck rule game vs. New England in 2001-2002.

 
9 of 25

Jeff Garcia

Jeff Garcia
Tom Hauck / Getty Images

Garcia began his pro career in the CFL before joining San Francisco in 1999. He made four Pro Bowls in an NFL career that started at age 29 and played for six different organizations over his 13-year NFL career.

 
10 of 25

Matt Hasselbeck

Matt Hasselbeck
Otto Greule Jr. / Getty Images

Hasselbeck made three Pro Bowls with the Seahawks and led the team to the Super Bowl in 2005-06 but lost to Pittsburgh. That's as far as he ever got in the playoffs. He was a backup to Andrew Luck in Indy for three years before leaving the NFL and eventually joining ESPN as an analyst. He ranks 26th in career passing yards.

 
11 of 25

Bert Jones

Bert Jones
George Gojkovich / Getty Images

Jones had a short career but claimed the 1976 MVP Award after passing for a league-leading 3,104 yards with the Baltimore Colts. He had an impressive three-year run with the Colts from 1975-77, going 31-11, but he started only 96 regular-season games for his career.

 
12 of 25

Sonny Jurgensen

Sonny Jurgensen
Nate Fine / Getty Images

Jurgensen was a five-time Pro Bowler and two-time All-Pro, with one of those All-Pro designations coming before the AFL-NFL merger. While he's able to claim an NFL championship in 1960, Jurgensen never won the big game after the merger. His passer rating was the best of his era, and he's a Pro Football Hall of Famer.

 
13 of 25

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly
Rick Stewart / Getty Images

Unfortunately the story of Buffalo's four Super Bowl losses with Kelly at the helm is how he's best remembered. For his career, Kelly made five Pro Bowls and First-Team All-Pro in 1991, leading to his Hall of Fame induction.

 
14 of 25

Dan Marino

Dan Marino
Sylvia Allen/Getty Images

With the incredible list of personal accomplishments, it's unbelievable that Marino never won a Super Bowl. Among his awards are 1983 NFL Rookie of the Year, 1984 MVP, nine Pro Bowls, three First-Team All-Pro designations and, of course, his Hall of Fame induction. He still ranks fifth in career passing yards while playing in an offensive era not nearly as pass-happy as the current one.

 
15 of 25

Donovan McNabb

Donovan McNabb
Al Bello / Getty Images

McNabb has a strong case for Hall of Fame induction after his Eagles career, making six Pro Bowls and winning NFC Offensive Player of the Year in 2004 en route to his only Super Bowl appearance. He's already enshrined in the Eagles Hall of Fame and has his No. 5 retired by the team. His 37,276 career passing yards rank 25th all time.

 
16 of 25

Steve McNair

Steve McNair
Joe Murphy / Getty Images

McNair made three Pro Bowls and quarterbacked the Titans to one Super Bowl appearance. He also won NFL MVP in 2003. McNair was a multidimensional quarterback who ranks 46th all time in career passing yards.

 
17 of 25

Warren Moon

Warren Moon
William R. Sallaz / Getty Images

While Moon won the CFL's Grey Cup five times, he failed to ever win a Super Bowl. For his NFL accomplishments, Moon did makes nine Pro Bowls and Second-Team All-Pro in 1990. He still ranks 11th all time in passing yards.

 
18 of 25

Carson Palmer

Carson Palmer
Christian Peterson / Getty Images

Palmer revitalized his career in Arizona after a great beginning with Cincinnati. The former first overall draft choice in 2003 retired after the 2017 season, making three Pro Bowls and ranking 14th all time in passing yards.

 
19 of 25

Chad Pennington

Chad Pennington
Mark Konezny / Getty Images

Pennington seems out of place on a list of best quarterbacks ever until taking a closer look at his credentials. Over his 11-year career, Pennington won Comeback Player of the Year twice, led the NFL in passer rating in 2002 and finished second in MVP voting to Peyton Manning in 2008. He also ranks third all time in completion percentage (66.0 percent) and 18th all time in passer rating.

 
20 of 25

Philip Rivers

Philip Rivers
Jonathan Daniel / Getty Images

The Chargers failed to make a Super Bowl in the 2000s despite some incredibly talented teams led by Rivers and LaDainian Tomlinson, but Rivers is still going strong in his late-30s. He's made eight Pro Bowls, ranks 10th all time in passer rating and sixth all time in passing yards. It's not impossible that Rivers will be considered the Chargers' best quarterback ever when he retires, overtaking Dan Fouts.

 
21 of 25

Tony Romo

Tony Romo
Elsa / Getty Images

Romo retired after the 2016 season and eventually joined the CBS broadcast booth. The media has enjoyed knocking his playoff failures, but Romo made the Pro Bowl four times and ranks fourth all time in passer rating. Those credentials could be enough to make him Hall of Fame-worthy.

 
22 of 25

Matt Ryan

Matt Ryan
Andy Lyons / Getty Images

Ryan's performance doesn't scream for an all-time list, but the stats state his case. Just 12 seasons into his career, Ryan ranks 10th all time in passing yards and has produced a 109-80 regular-season record. He's also made four Pro Bowls and won the 2016 MVP.

 
23 of 25

Brian Sipe

Brian Sipe
George Rose / Getty Images

Sipe had only one great year, winning the 1980 NFL MVP in what was also his only Pro Bowl appearance. He played 10 seasons with the Browns before finishing his football career in the USFL.

 
24 of 25

Fran Tarkenton

Fran Tarkenton
Focus on Sport

Today's multidimensional quarterbacks are still compared to Tarkenton. The Hall of Famer made nine Pro Bowls, won the 1975 MVP and appeared in three Super Bowls with the Vikings. He still ranks 12th in career passing yards and also rushed for 3,674 yards and 32 touchdowns over his career.

 
25 of 25

Michael Vick

Michael Vick
Kevin C. Cox / Getty Images

Vick never put up the best passing numbers, but during his prime there were few players whom fans wanted to see more. He made four Pro Bowls and won the 2010 Comeback Player of the Year Award with the Eagles after time in prison. One of the greatest rushing quarterbacks ever, Vick ran for 6,109 yards and 36 touchdowns over his career.

Seth Trachtman

Seth Trachtman is a sportswriter, digital marketer, and fantasy sports expert based in St. Louis, Missouri. He’s a two-time winner of the Tout Wars Fantasy Baseball Expert’s League, and his work has appeared in hundreds of fantasy baseball and fantasy football newsstand and online publications

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!