Frugality tends to be a good trait for an NFL general manager. They need to be careful with the contracts they give out to ensure they don't run into salary cap trouble a few years down the road and have to part with an elite player. Sometimes, however, you just have to pay the man what he says he deserves, and that's what Chicago Bears GM Ryan Poles should have done for running back David Montgomery.
We'll never know for sure the details of Poles' offer, but when Montgomery signed with the Detroit Lions in 2023, the rumor was that it was an identical offer in terms of years and total money but that Detroit offered a little bit more guaranteed cash than Poles did. Poles made a business decision with Montgomery's contract, and Montgomery did the same.
Since then, Bears fans have been infuriated with the state of Chicago's run game, especially after Justin Fields was traded and could no longer juice the numbers with his electric scrambles. Chicago's futility in the run game was on full display Sunday, when starting running back D'Andre Swift averaged a meager 2.5 yards per carry.
Fast forward to Monday Night Football, where Bears fans had to sit and watch their former running back have a career game, gaining 151 yards on just 12 carries and scoring a pair of touchdowns. Obviously, this is not the kind of performance Montgomery can put on every week, but it just serves to remind the Bears of what they once had, and what they allowed to leave over a matter of a percentage or two of the salary cap.
Montgomery making a house call #DETvsBAL ESPN/ABC pic.twitter.com/IcmmvCGHHT
— Detroit Lions (@Lions) September 23, 2025
While Swift tends to go down at the first contact with the defense, Montgomery, who said that the 2025 season would be a 'year of reckoning', powers forward and picks up extra yards. He's a hard hitter that wears down a defense so that, by the end of the game, they're softened up and can be picked apart. This is exactly the kind of dynamic weapon the Bears could use right now, if only they'd kept Montgomery happy.
What head coach Ben Johnson's offense would look like with Montgomery carrying the load is up to Bears fans' imagination, but it would almost certainly be much better than what they have now.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!