The New York Giants' main message throughout the entire offseason was about the need for the franchise to start fast in their 2025 campaign and accumulate more wins, a goal they thought would be aided by the partnership with Russell Wilson as their starting quarterback.
Just three games into the season, the Giants have yet to record a victory. The offense certainly hasn't helped the cause, as Wilson has looked like a shell of his former self, throwing for a combined 778 yards, three touchdowns, and three interceptions. As a result, New York has fallen into a quick 0-3 hole with the NFL's toughest schedule rolling along.
With the year sliding out of control and pressure building on the team's current regime battling to retain faith from ownership that they can still right the organization that hasn't seen consistent success over the past 15 seasons, head coach Brian Daboll has decided the time has come for him to put all his chips at the middle of the table and see if his rookie prodigy, Jaxson Dart, can provide a dire spark.
The decision announced on Tuesday and confirmed by Daboll on Wednesday officially ends the Wilson experiment in East Rutherford. Many are questioning whether the seemingly desperate move by the head coach was made too early in Dart's process.
Not to former Giants quarterback and two-time Super Bowl champion Phil Simms, who, on an appearance on SiriusXM's Mad Dog Sports Radio, said he strongly backs the move by the Giants and believes there was truly no better time for the franchise to hand over the reins to the apprentice.
“Did they have to play him this week? Yes. They had to," Simms said to host Adam Schein.
"I'm sitting at home watching the Kansas City game, and I see all the empty seats. … and owners, they know empty seats too. And you have to listen to the public sometimes, because when they don't show up, that’s a big deal.”
The overall scene at MetLife Stadium for the Giants' home opener against the then-winless Chiefs was certainly not something for John Mara and ownership to take pride in, as it appeared the fans might be starting to lose interest in the team.
It was clear that a good chunk of the fans in attendance were donning the red colors of the visiting team, and audible groans were coming from the Giants on the two rare occasions that Daboll threw Dart in for a snap or two before going back to Wilson.
Wilson, who told reporters that he is not done as a professional following his benching by the Giants, had his final straw come in a dismal primetime performance, where he threw two interceptions and couldn't get one of his 32 pass attempts into the end zone.
Thus, to avoid completely losing the fanbase and continuing to stake his job on a flopping offense that needed a fresh face to put some energy back into it with 14 games left, Daboll made his lasting switch to Dart, whom some folks thought wouldn't see the field for upwards of a couple of months.
“I hear all the people talking… ‘Well, they need to sit him for the whole year. He shouldn't play until week 10.’ That is nuts," Simms added.
"I thought Jaxson Dart would sit on the sidelines for maybe four or five games. You stand over there, Adam. I was one of these guys. I was just a fan of the first game or two, like, ‘yeah, this is pretty cool,’ being on the sideline and watching the game."
"And then week three, I remember looking out there going, ‘you know, I can do this.’ And then by week four, you're like, ‘shoot, when are they gonna play me?’ And I'm sure Jaxson Dart is kind of in that same mold. “
Simms even agreed that Dart is the type of quarterback prospect whose intangibles he initially overlooked until he saw them in person at the Giants' summer training camp practices. He quickly learned that the young player was primed to take over the starting job at some point in the season.
“He's sneaky, really good at running the football. … I've underrated his ability to run up the middle and to gain yards and get it fast. And the other thing is he's a big dude, man. He's big, he's thick, he can take punishment, and he can deliver it, too."
“Yeah, he's a rookie, but this offense is not going to look the same. It's going to be a big difference. It's going to have energy. They're going to call plays, and you're going to go, Wow, I didn't expect that. I mean, that's what I think will happen.”
The Giants might have made it clear that Wilson would begin the year as their starting arm and remain there so long as his experience and presence in the pocket were leading to positive results on the scoreboard.
That simply hasn't been the case through three games, and it's going to take their gamble on Dart in the draft panning out to salvage what's left.
If he can't translate his game to the big leagues and vindicate the regime's decision, all bets could then be off, as they will have run out of cards to deal, and vast changes could be in store for the offseason.
As of now, the Giants' brass doesn't seem to be alone in their belief that Dart is the answer, as the great gunslingers of the franchise's past see the present opportunity as Dart's to seize and start building his legacy in that timeline.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!