The Miami Dolphins entered the offseason knowing their wide receiver room would look drastically different after moving on from Tyreek Hill and trading Jaylen Waddle.
Tutu Atwell was supposed to help fill that void. Instead, Miami traded Atwell back to the Los Angeles Rams before the regular season even began, receiving running back Jarquez Hunter in return.
So where does that leave Miami’s receivers?
In my opinion, 32nd in the NFL, and it’s difficult to argue otherwise.
ESPN’s Mike Clay already ranked Miami’s wide receiver room dead last in the league when Atwell was still on the roster. Now the Dolphins’ official depth chart lists rookie Caleb Douglas, Malik Washington and Jalen Tolbert as their three starting receivers, with Kevin Coleman Jr., Chris Bell and Jalen Reagor behind them.
There is certainly upside there, particularly with the rookies. But there is almost no proven NFL production. Washington recorded 46 receptions for 317 yards and three touchdowns last season. His 540 career receiving yards are actually among the most established production Miami has at the position.
Tolbert has more experience, but he followed a 610-yard, seven-touchdown 2024 season with only 203 yards and one touchdown in 2025. Douglas, meanwhile, could legitimately enter Week 1 as one of Miami’s primary receivers despite never playing an NFL regular-season snap.
That’s the problem.
Atwell was never an established NFL WR1 himself. But after Miami dismantled the Hill-Waddle combination, he was positioned to become one of the Dolphins’ top receiving options. Trading him before Week 1 tells you just how developmental this group has become. Maybe Douglas or Bell becomes a steal. Maybe Washington takes a significant third-year jump. Maybe Tolbert recaptures his 2024 production, but those are all just projections.
For a quarterback like Malik Willis, who is already attempting to prove he can become a legitimate NFL starter, Miami is asking him to do it with arguably the league’s least proven receiving corps.
There are reasons to be excited about the future.
Entering 2026, however, the Dolphins have the No. 32 wide receiver room in football until someone proves otherwise.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!