Yardbarker
x
Is it time to question the Carolina Panthers' coaching staff after another disaster?
Sep 7, 2025; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars head coach Liam Coen and Carolina Panthers head coach Dave Canales shake hands following the game at EverBank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

The Carolina Panthers were outplayed on Sunday, but they were also thoroughly outcoached by a remade staff led by a first-year head coach. It was an embarrassing loss on all levels, even if winning on the road against a better team on paper was always going to be a challenge.

Dave Canales had a bad day out there, and it's fair to wonder whether, after a full season calling the shots, it's time to question him and the rest of the staff. QB Bryce Young has questions hurled at him about his future, but the coaching staff has thus far avoided much of the same.

That's not to say there haven't been concerns. Folks have begged for Carolina to fire DC Ejiro Evero for years. Canales certainly came under fire for Sunday's loss, but is it all warranted? At this point, it's hard to say no.

Canales has a few shortcomings in his coaching game that are very hard to overcome, one of them being inconsistent playcalling. At times, he makes good calls and comes up with clever, creative, successful plays. Far too often, he resorts to bad, vanilla playcalling that hurts the Panthers.

There are a couple of examples from Sunday. During the second quarter, Canales was calling exclusively runs and short passes, operating in a very timid fashion, and it led to a very poor outcome. He didn't get better as the game went on.

It is almost indefensible to get to third-and-one at the five-yard line and call a shotgun draw play. A draw is designed to catch the defense off guard. It's not going to surprise anyone and can only allow the D-line to get a push on an obvious run play. Unsurprisingly, it didn't work.

The coach then followed it up by going shotgun empty set with five wide receivers when he needed just a few feet. Bryce Young couldn't find anyone, and there seemed to be a miscommunication on where Xavier Legette was supposed to be, but the QB was unhappy.

He also seems to have trouble deciding what to do in those situations. On that fourth-and-one, the Panthers should've kicked it. Yes, they needed a touchdown, but a TD cut it to a two-score game. A field goal would've also cut it to two scores and given them a positive result to build on.

Canales also passed up on another field goal try and punted. It's fair to be cautious with a rookie kicker who barely won the camp battle, but the Panthers coach has done this more than just once on Sunday.

The head coach also seems to think he has a team ready to compete in the NFL and win, which is why he keeps starters out but for four series in the preseason. That only works when your team is pretty good, which the Panthers aren't. Two years in a row, they've looked utterly out of sorts in Week 1, and it has to be because they're not getting a lot of reps together.

It's really unclear what OC Brad Idzik brings to the table aside from being Canales' guy from Seattle and Tampa Bay, but it might be better if he had a seasoned former head coach OC to help in the areas that Canales struggles in.

As for Ejiro Evero on the other side of the ball, there have been far too many bad seasons under him to continue ignoring it. There is a major talent deficit on that side of the ball, but Evero seems to refuse to want to try other options to make it work.

The Panthers pressured Trevor Lawrence the least among all NFL QBs on Sunday, and Evero refused to even try rookie edge rushers Nic Scourton and Princely Umanmielen, who played a combined 26 snaps. Lathan Ransom sat for all but nine snaps in favor of Nick Scott, a glorified special teamer.

On that note, Canales seems to have no idea that he's the head coach and can instruct his assistants to do things. He revealed yesterday that he's asked Evero to play those young guys more, when in reality, he could just have him play those players.

However, just like with Young, it's not quite time to call for Canales' head. Growing pains were always likely given his rapid ascension from assistant to coordinator to head coach. We've seen things work really well for both Young and Canales together, so it's not time to fire him just yet. That would be what the old Panthers who kept cycling through coaches and QBs did, and that's not who the team needs to be anymore.

  

This article first appeared on Carolina Panthers on SI and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!