When the Falcons handed Kirk Cousins a $180 million contract and then spent the 8th overall pick on Michael Penix Jr. just a few weeks later, they essentially invited a quarterback controversy to Atlanta — and that’s exactly what they’ve gotten.
Last season, Cousins was named the unquestioned starter heading into the year, and for about nine weeks, everything was going according to plan. The Falcons were 6-3, comfortably in first place in the NFC South, and looked poised to make the playoffs for the first time since 2017.
Then came the Week 10 matchup against the Saints. Not only did Atlanta lose to its division rival, but Cousins suffered an injury that clearly impacted his play. He tried to gut it out, but he looked like a shell of himself, and the Falcons proceeded to drop their next three games.
The calls for rookie Michael Penix Jr. became deafening, and the Falcons eventually caved, naming him the starter for the final three weeks of the season.
Penix showed enough flashes over that stretch to earn the full-time starting job heading into 2025. But if the organization thought that would put an end to the quarterback controversy while Cousins was still on the roster, they were only fooling themselves.
After a pair of lackluster performances in Weeks 2 and 3, the questions are already surfacing: Is there a quarterback competition in Atlanta?
Raheem Morris shot that idea down after the Falcons’ embarrassing 30-0 loss to the Panthers, but he also cracked the door ever so slightly, suggesting that it could be a possibility down the line — something that never should have come out of his mouth.
Head Coach Raheem Morris says there is not a competition for QB between Michael Penix Jr. and Kirk Cousins.
I asked him if it's because it was only one bad game- instead of multiple for Penix.He said Yeah thats fair to say.– He believes Michael Penix Jr will bounce back this…
— Alison Mastrangelo (@AlisonWSB) September 24, 2025
Raheem Morris isn’t doing himself any favors with these kinds of answers, and he needs to be better moving forward because these questions aren’t going anywhere.
Most recently, Falcons reporter Zach Klein asked Matt Ryan on The Inner Circle podcast why there shouldn’t be a quarterback competition between Cousins and Penix.
“What kind of competition do you think is going to happen at practice this week?” Ryan asked. “He had his opportunity. He played last year and showcased what he did. He had his chance. When you’re playing games with your quarterback position after you drafted somebody top 10 overall, you got a great chance of screwing this up six starts into it when you start playing games like that… You don’t overreact to one horrible loss.”
It’s sad to say, but Raheem Morris could stand to take a page out of Matt Ryan’s book on how to handle these questions. The door to any quarterback controversy should be slammed shut — loudly and publicly — by the head coach. There is no going back to a 40-year-old Kirk Cousins under any circumstances unless Michael Penix Jr. gets hurt. Period.
The fact that Raheem Morris didn’t make that crystal clear in the immediate aftermath of a 30-0 loss to the Panthers is just the latest sign that he might not be fit to lead an NFL team.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!