New Reporting Shows NFL Botched Critical Rams 3rd Down Call vs. Eagles

Get your Puka-Flex T-Shirt Here

Late in the third quarter, Nacua made a critical third-down reception, a 20-yard grab that would have kept the Rams’ drive alive. During the broadcast, Fox analysts repeatedly noted that “replay assist gets involved” and that the play had been overturned. After a commercial break, the call was ultimately ruled a completion following the Rams’ challenge, seemingly confirming the catch.

However, reporting from Mike Florio of ProFootballTalk clarified that, according to the league, replay assist was never involved, and the Fox broadcast crew had been misled. Florio noted, “As far as the league is concerned, replay assist was never involved — and that the Fox broadcast crew was incorrect.”

This incident highlights the ongoing ambiguity surrounding replay assist in the NFL. The tool is intended for “obvious and correctable” errors, yet its application remains inconsistent. There have already been instances this season where replay assist could have intervened, but didn’t — such as Dolphins receiver Tyreek Hill’s sideline bobble, which went unreviewed.

Taunting Penalty Adds to Frustration

Adding to the confusion, Nacua was flagged for taunting immediately following the catch. The receiver flexed and pointed toward the end zone, actions he described as routine celebration in line with plays he’s executed previously. According to ESPN NFL Nation’s Sarah Barshop, Nacua noted that his celebration was no different than Eagles receiver A.J. Brown’s similar on-field displays, which went unpenalized.

Red Zone Woes Continue

Beyond officiating missteps, the Rams’ struggles in the red zone persisted. Sunday’s game marked only their sixth red-zone touchdown in 14 attempts this season, a 43% conversion rate that would have ranked last in the NFL last year. Head coach Sean McVay summed it up bluntly: “Ultimately, not being able to finish in the red area, we weren’t good enough on third downs… credit to them, they ended up making some plays, they got back in it.”

Multiple factors contributed, from questionable play-calling to missed throws by Matthew Stafford, including a 6-yard slant to Davante Adams with ample separation. Penalties, such as Coleman Shelton’s holding call nullifying Kyren Williams’ rushing touchdown, further hindered the Rams’ progress.

Looking Ahead

Despite the loss, there were bright spots: Nacua finished with 11 catches for 112 yards, and the defense held the Eagles scoreless in the first half. Still, Sunday’s defeat was a reminder that close games can hinge on execution, red-zone efficiency, and clear officiating. The Rams will have another test next week against the 3-0 Indianapolis Colts at SoFi Stadium.