Peyton Manning Detailed If Steelers' Chase For Aaron Rodgers Actually Makes Sense

Even former quarterback Peyton Manning was asked about Rodgers' situation while out on the golf course. During a brief exchange with 97.1 The Fan, Manning was questioned on whether Rodgers could lead the Steelers to meaningful wins in 2025. With Manning offering a big answer, the conversation added another layer to the ongoing buzz surrounding Rodgers and Pittsburgh.

"I think so," Manning said. "Look, the guy is super talented—probably has, arguably, one of the best arms of all time. It’s just kinda elastic. I don’t have any insight on that, but hopefully he gets with a team soon and kinda gets going. Would be fun to see him back on the field."

Manning is widely regarded as one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game, so hearing his thoughts on the Steelers' pursuit of Rodgers carries weight. Manning isn’t just a legend; he's a true student of the game who stays deeply involved through his ManningCast coverage of primetime games on ESPN. 

His support for the idea of Rodgers in Pittsburgh adds a layer of credibility to the possibility and has certainly sparked even more excitement among fans. When someone with Manning’s football IQ and perspective backs the move, it naturally gives the idea more legitimacy around the league.

Manning believes Rodgers still has meaningful football left in him. Even at 41 years old and coming off a 2024 season in which his team won just five games, Manning remains confident that Rodgers can still deliver. He trusts that Rodgers' arm talent and experience can defy Father Time for at least another year. 

His understanding of quarterback longevity adds depth to the conversation. Rodgers’ football IQ, pocket awareness, and ability to make off-platform throws are still among the best in the NFL. That’s an encouraging sign for Steelers fans hoping for one last elite run from a quarterback with Rodgers’ pedigree.

Steelers' Backup Plan If Aaron Rodgers Doesn't Come

If Rodgers doesn’t end up in Pittsburgh, the Steelers are expected to move forward with Mason Rudolph as the starter. Skylar Thompson and rookie Will Howard would likely battle for the backup spot. While that scenario isn't ideal, the addition of Rodgers would immediately give the team its best shot at competing in 2025. 

His arrival would not only stabilize the quarterback position but also energize a franchise hungry to return to postseason relevance. With a strong defense and an emerging run game, Rodgers could be the missing piece Pittsburgh needs to make a serious push. He also could create a ton of drama and distractions if he comes to the Steel City. Either way the 2025 season is certain to be interesting.