When the dust cleared, the Philadelphia Eagles had lost their first game in 287 days.
DeVonta Smith and A.J. Brown lay atop one another in the end zone, both without the football. Jalen Hurts, who took off toward his own pass 40 yards down the field, pulled up at the goal line with his head tilted. It was the first time he had finished a game and lost in over a year.
The sky is not falling, but it is shaded. Another stale second-half performance left the Denver Broncos in the game far too long. Inevitably, they jumped in front, scoring the final 18 points to steal one on the road in Philly.
With the loss, one narrative has dissipated. They always find a way.
This time, they did not. In fact, it felt like they found a way to lose. The Eagles have been outscored 37-14 in the second half over the past two weeks. In 2024, the second half was an advantage, ranking second in the NFL in scoring.
Anyone can tell that something is not right. This simply does not happen to an intact Super Bowl core, an offensive group viewed as The Avengers and an all-star cast that scored nearly 100 points over two games to win a championship.
How can it look like this?
Philadelphia elected continuity when it promoted longtime assistant Kevin Patullo to offensive coordinator, following the departure of Kellen Moore.
Since 2018, Patullo has been down the hall from Nick Sirianni, migrating from Indianapolis to Philly after Sirianni was hired in 2021. Without a head coach calling plays, this was as familiar as it would get from one headset to the next.
Patullo’s timid style of attack has kept the Eagles’ adversaries in every single game in 2025.
Through five games, Hurts has thrown 24 pass attempts traveling 10 or more yards. That is less than his old teammate and journeyman Carson Wentz, who has appeared in three games. While only Justin Herbert has been blitzed more than Hurts, the Eagles’ quarterback still cracks the top 10 in time to throw.
The issues run deeper than shallow depth. Despite a clear unwillingness to take risks downfield, Hurts is still throwing into tight windows 17.3% of the time, eighth most, according to NFL Next Gen Stats. Notably, that number was just over 4% in the season opener versus Dallas. It has been much higher ever since.
That calls on play design. Here is a third down and long, with the Eagles just outside of field goal range. The Broncos heavily disguise a zone look, showing a blitz.
10) You all know this by now, but in the 2nd half, the Broncos stopped blitzing (largely) and played more zone, and the Eagles do not have answers. They don't know how to stress zone defenses at all. This was 3rd and long.
You can discuss Hurts being weaker against zone… pic.twitter.com/LQ5rndUnaI
— Jonny Page (@JonnyPage9) October 6, 2025
The results back it up. A.J. Brown’s comments sparked controversy following a win over the Buccaneers in Week 4. The Eagles completed zero (zero!) passes in the second half of that game, whilst Tampa Bay furiously stormed back. It was the only such occasion across the entire NFL over the last two seasons.
“I think it’s normal to have frustrations because of the standard we hold ourselves to,” said Brown. “To be honest, defense and special teams have been low-key carrying us.”
Apart from a gritty effort after the intermission against the Rams, the Birds have mightily struggled with mid-game adjustments from opposing defenses.
Not only are the playcalls ineffective, but they are also tardy. Philadelphia has struggled to get to the line time and again in 2025. Rushing from the huddle prevents Hurts from checking plays or processing defenses pre-snap. Their struggles have come at a historic rate.
Looking back at the entire Hurts/Sirianni era, the #Eagles have always been slower than almost all other teams at snapping the ball, but through 5 games, this 2025 version is an extreme outlier from all of the other 159 team-seasons in this period. https://t.co/daWsc45C4x pic.twitter.com/T53D5Sn5PG
— Deniz Selman (@denizselman33) October 7, 2025
Offensive woes have seeped into late-game breakdowns on the other side of the ball as well. The Eagles’ defense has played over 70 snaps in consecutive weeks. The offense has gone three-and-out in 47% of its drives in 2025. When the offense stalls, just as it did Sunday versus Denver, Philly defenders wear down.
Playcalling, scheme, or otherwise, it is not conducive to success.
Tough sledding offensively was a problem in 2024, too, with more of Brown’s remarks making headlines late in the regular season. But Moore’s adaptability throughout games and over the course of the season allowed the Eagles to hit their stride as the magnitude of games grew. Maybe Patullo is still finding his footing, but a stable solution sits in the shadows as well.
Nick Sirianni gave up his playcalling duties sometime during his debut season in Philadelphia, and has since left the onus on his coordinators– beginning with Shane Steichen, and continuing through Brian Johnson, Moore, and Patullo. During Sirianni’s time in Indianapolis, Frank Reich called plays.
While Sirianni has instead opted to focus on leadership, the constant turnover of voices in Hurts’s helmet is becoming increasingly burdensome. The prosperous have taken head coaching gigs elsewhere, and the unsuccessful have been let go. With no end in sight, the chain may need to be broken.
Exactly half of the league’s head coaches call offensive plays. Barring any shocking development, Sirianni will be in Philadelphia for the foreseeable future, after receiving a multi-year extension this offseason. With Hurts dealing with his sixth new playcaller in as many seasons, there may be no time better than the present.
Patullo is still learning the ropes and will take a different approach after the recent heaps of criticism. But the offense that boasts Pro Bowl talent at nearly every position has been lifeless and stagnant.
Last season’s trip to the pinnacle formed a kevlar vest around offensive struggles. And while they were excused due to an unbeaten start, the Eagles will be taking a long look in the mirror as they look to better utilize the many strengths of a painstakingly constructed offense.
If the problem persists, Philadelphia will have some tough decisions to make.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!