
According to Dave Pagnotta of the Fourth Period, the Montreal Canadiens trade deadline deal that was, in fact, filed a minute too late and therefore couldn’t go through would have centred on Toronto Maple Leafs power forward Matthew Knies in the deal that Pagnotta claimed that the Habs would have sent top prospect Alexander Zharovsky, two 1st round picks, and another top prospect (not Michael Hage or David Reinbacher). Knies would have been a great fit for the Habs given his age and style of play. However, the question remains: should the Canadiens circle back to that trade in the off-season?
According to David Pagnotta, the Habs had a trade in place with the Leafs for Matthew Knies in exchange for Alexander Zharovsky, another top prospect and two 1st round draft picks.
The 2nd prospect was not Michael Hage nor David Reinbacher.Would you have made this trade?
https://t.co/kLYBzNS6qu
— /r/Habs (@HabsOnReddit) June 4, 2026
Elliotte Friedman then reported on his 32 Thoughts podcast that the reason the deal didn’t go through was that it got into the queue at 3:01 pm ET. While Friedman believes that the Habs would like to revisit the deal, he thinks with new management in Toronto it is very unlikely to happen.
Elliotte Friedman on the potential Matthew Knies trade from the Leafs to the Habs for Alexander Zharovsky, a top prospect and two 1st round picks:
“The reason it didn’t happen, it was submitted at 3:01 pm…I think it’s possible Montreal wanted to revisit it but I don’t believe… pic.twitter.com/aNExSucMrw
— /r/Habs (@HabsOnReddit) June 5, 2026
Another bombshell about the deal that was released on Friday morning was that, according to media member Jonah Sigel, Habs GM Kent Hughes was very angry at Leafs GM at the time Brad Treliving about the trade going into the queue at 3:01 pm ET. Hughes allegedly said to Treliving that if he isn’t fired in the off-season, then he better honour this deal. Unfortunately, he was let go, and so it will be harder for the trade to go through.
Now that the Leafs are under a new management group, there is a high possibility that this trade won’t even be entertained by the team anymore. Although, now that the details have been reported, it could make players involved feel awkward staying with their current teams, especially Knies, who would have been shipped over to arguably the Leafs’ biggest rivals. Therefore, at the very least the Habs and Leafs should consider circling back on that with Zharovsky being the main piece going back the other way since it’s out there.
According to @yyzsportsmedia, Kent Hughes was quite angry with Brad Treliving after the Knies trade was submitted at 3:01PM at the trade deadline
pic.twitter.com/4u2lvoL0Up
— HFTV (@HFTVSports) June 5, 2026
I personally believe that when a trade falls through and the names are revealed, those guys named need to end up getting dealt in the end to avoid any awkwardness. At the same time, a new management group could remove any tension between the Leafs and Knies, so we will see if they even want to go forth with a trade.
If anything, the Habs could trade Zharovsky in another deal to go get that elusive 2nd line centre that they are looking to get this summer. However, based on the fact that the Canadiens would have traded him in a package for a young winger, it seems like they have a lot of faith that Hage can be their 2nd line centre of the future. With that being said, don’t be surprised if the Habs do end up with Knies or another young winger instead of a centre as long as Hage is still in the organization.
Based on what we have been hearing for the last while, the Habs want to keep both Hage and Reinbacher, as they believe those players to be big parts of the future. It will remain to be seen if these two end up being as big a part of the organization as the management is hoping for; unless it’s for a star player around their age, the Habs will likely hang on to those two players.
As for the Canadiens being able to circle back…
I think there are teams that can beat a reported package of Zharovsky, D prospect (likely Engstrom or Pickford), and two 1sts.
That's if John Chayka even entertains serious trade talks.
— Marco D'Amico (@mndamico) June 5, 2026
As for the final piece that wasn’t revealed in the said trade for Knies, RG Media’s Marco D’Amico believes the other top prospect could be one of two defensemen in Bryce Pickford or Adam Engstrom. These two don’t have the upside that Hage or Reinbacher have, but at the same time, they both have a good chance to be regular NHLers one day.
Hearing that the trade for Knies came in a minute after the deadline definitely hurts, as someone like him would be the perfect fit next to Nick Suzuki and Cole Caufield or could also have been a good linemate for Ivan Demidov. Knies finished with a very solid 23 goals and 66 points in 79 games as one of the few Leafs players who had a solid season. At age 23, he will only get better, and with that being said, he was worth the package Zharovsky, Engstrom/Pickford, and two late-1st rounders that the Canadiens offered, especially since there is no guarantee any of these players come close to what Knies can bring.
According to @FriedgeHNIC , a trade that would have sent Matthew Knies to Montreal reportedly fell through because it was submitted less than a minute after the deadline.
How different would the Canadiens look today if that deal had gone through?
Selon @FriedgeHNIC , une… pic.twitter.com/bxba9ek8pz
— The Sick Podcast with Tony Marinaro (@thesickpodcasts) June 5, 2026
Do you hope that the Canadiens try to circle back to this potential trade, or do you think they should look elsewhere?
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!